军事知识服务平台
数字产品合理差别待遇的法理证成与规范实现
The Legal Justification and Regulatory Implementation of"Reasonable Differential Treatment"for Digital Products
摘要 非歧视待遇规则在数字产品语境下面临适用困境,相关规制范式亟须转型.数字产品属性的模糊性与数字鸿沟的加剧,共同消解了形式平等规则得以有效运行的前提条件,而现有法定例外条款亦难以充分适配数字领域多元、复杂的规制诉求.在此背景下,数字产品合理差别待遇可被理解为非歧视原则在数字语境下的内在延伸,其正当性植根于实质平等价值导向与国家规制权二者的结构性平衡关系.基于这一规范定位,可相应构建以目的合法性、实质关联性、必要性与比例性为核心的认定标准,并通过证明责任分配与审查强度的制度安排,确保规则运行的稳定性.在立法文本层面,合理差别待遇应以内嵌方式置于非歧视规则体系之中.立足该制度建构路径,中国可依托国内法治支撑与数字丝绸之路的实践积累,推动全球数字贸易秩序向更加公平与包容的方向演进.
Abstract:
In the context of digital products,non-discrimination rules face challenges in application and are undergoing a paradigm shift.The ambiguity of digital product attributes,coupled with the widening digital divide,has eroded the prerequisites for the effective operation of formal equality rules,while statutory exceptions struggle to adequately address the diverse and complex demands of digital regulation.Against this backdrop,reasonable differential treatment of digital products can be understood as an intrinsic extension of the principle of non-discrimination in the digital context,with its legitimacy rooted in the structural balance between the orientation toward substantive equality and the state's regulatory authority.Based on this normative positioning,assessment criteria centered on the legitimacy of purpose,substantive relevance,and necessity and proportionality can be established accordingly.Furthermore,institutional arrangements regarding the allocation of the burden of proof and the intensity of review can ensure the stability of the rule's operation.At the level of legislative texts,reasonable differential treatment should be embedded within the system of non-discrimination rules.Based on this institutional approach,China can leverage the support of its domestic rule-of-law system and the practical experience accumulated through the Digital Silk Road to promote the evolution of the global digital trade order toward greater equity and inclusivity.
刊 名 现代法学 ISTICPKU
年,卷(期): 2026, 48(4)
分类号: DF96
机标分类号: G640 D925.1 F724.6
在线出版日期: 2026年9月8日