帮助信息网络犯罪活动罪的法益构造及其限定路径
The Legal Interest Structure and Restricted Paths of Assisting Information Network Criminal Activities
摘要
层级法益观不仅无法合理说明"情节严重"的必要性,而且还在法益侵害的认定上存在循环论证的问题,因此有必要回归单层法益视角对本罪的保护法益予以明示.在法益侵害的具体判断方面,应当明确区分判断对象与判断资料,将对下游犯罪的具体侵害作为判断信息网络安全秩序是否受到减损的资料.在具体构成要件要素的解释方面,为了降低竞合型立法化所带来的负面效应,应当将主观明知理解为对下游犯罪的高度认识可能性;"他人犯罪"只需要行为人的高度认识可能性,因此属于客观的超过要素;而"二年内曾……受过行政处罚"不能表明具体的法益侵害危险,因此是证明行为人主观明知的判断资料.
The hierarchical approach not only fails to rationally explain the necessity of"serious circumstances",but also presents a problem of circular reasoning in determining the infringement of legal interests,therefore,it is necessary to return to a single-tier legal interest perspective to elucidate the protective legal interests of this offense.Regarding the specific judgment of legal interest infringement,a clear distinction should be made between the object of judgment and the evidence for judgment,the specific harm to downstream crimes should be considered as evidence to determine whether the information network security order has been impaired.In terms of interpreting specific elements of the constitutive requirements,to mitigate the negative effects of competing legislations,subjective knowledge should be understood as a high likelihood of awareness of downstream crimes;"another person's crime"should be treated as an objective exceeding element,as it only requires the actor's high likelihood of awareness;"having been subject to administrative penalties within two years"should be considered evidence for proving the actor's subjective knowledge,as it does not represent specific risks of legal interest infringement.
年,卷(期):
2023, 76(4)
机标分类号:
D924.3
D631
TP393.08
在线出版日期:
2026年10月12日
基金项目:
2023RBYJGL-12:国家民族事务委员会一带一路国别和区域研究中心——日本应急管理研究中心一般项目,