误区与纠偏:防卫过当司法认定实证研究
Misunderstanding and Correction:An Empirical Study on Judicial Identification of Excessive Defense
摘要
对2020~2021年192份裁判文书进行Logistic回归分析可以发现司法实践中防卫过当认定的影响因素与判断逻辑.结果表明:双方当事人认识情况、侵害人持凶器情况、案发起因、侵害次数和持续时间、侵害停止后是否停止防卫、动手顺序以及防卫人是否逃离现场对防卫过当的认定具有显著影响.综合分析回归结果、裁判逻辑和理论契合关系可知:实务中防卫限度的认定出现了一定松动,表现在伤亡结果并不影响防卫正当性的认定,但影响正当防卫的成立;法益衡量片面化和简单化,表现在防卫法益限缩于生命健康权,自由权、人格权保障不足,不法侵害限缩为暴力侵害;对防卫意思必要说不当理解,混淆了防卫故意与犯罪故意,导致防卫行为被认定为互殴、防卫过当被认定为故意犯罪.今后,防卫限度的判断应当以"必需说"为基本立场,进一步扩大正当防卫的成立范围.
Through logistics regression analysis of 192 judicial documents from 2020 to 2021,the influencing factors and judgment logic of excessive defense identification in judicial practice can be found.The results show that the cognition of both parties,the situation of the assailant holding the weapon,the cause of the incident,the number and duration of the assault,whether the defense stops after the assault,the sequence of the assault and whether the defender escapes from the scene have significant influence on the identification of excessive defense.Comprehensive analysis of regression results,judgment logic and theoretical fit shows that:the identification of defense limit in practice has become loose,which is manifested in the casualty results do not affect the identification of defense legitimacy,but affect the establishment of justifiable defense;the measure of legal interest is one-sided and simplified,which shows that the limit of legal interest of defense is reduced to life and health,the protection of freedom and personality is insufficient,and the illegal infringement is reduced to violence;improper understanding of the meaning of defense confuses the intent of defense with the intent of crime,which leads to the defense behavior being identified as fighting,and the excessive defense is identified as the intent of crime.In the future,the judgment of the limit of defense should take"necessity theory"as the basic standpoint,and further expand the scope of justifiable defense.
年,卷(期):
2023, 76(4)
机标分类号:
D924.3
R743.3
R183
在线出版日期:
2026年10月12日