军事知识服务平台
异源视角下的实质作为义务研究
Research on Substance as Obligation from a Multi-source Perspective
摘要 规范违反和事实支配均无法为不纯正不作为犯的作为义务提供完整的说明.作为义务的来源包括制度性义务和支配性义务.制度性义务包括保护义务和监督义务.基于法的安定性,保护义务限定为在社会生活中持续性地负有保护义务的场合,是针对个人法益类的犯罪;需要考察法律的明确规定,"刑法保护利益面临紧迫的危险"、"法益对保护义务人的直接依赖性"和"行为人没有为消除这种危险的特定举动"客观方面的事实要素.监督义务的发生是为了维护社会秩序——因规范目的建构起来的功能关系,其内容是基于制度的要求防止危险源对其他法益的侵害.先前行为产生"不能制造危险"的支配性义务,判断要点是行为人是否事实上开启了法益侵害的流程,是真正的结果原因支配.未制造危险、无特别义务的一般不救助行为不构成犯罪.
Abstract:
Neither normative violation nor factual control can provide a complete explanation for the conduct obligation in the case of impure omissions.As the source of obligations,there are institutional obligations and dominant obligations.Institutional obligations include protection obligations and monitoring obligations.Based on the stability of the law,the obligation to protect is limited to crimes against personal legal interests in situations where the obligation to protect continues in social life;it is necessary to examine the clear provisions of the law and objective aspects that"criminal law protects interests facing imminent danger"and"legal interests direct dependence on the person obliged to protect"and"the actor did not take specific actions to eliminate the danger"fact elements.The occurrence of supervisory obligations is to maintain social order,a functional relationship constructed for normative purposes,and its content is based on the requirements of the system to prevent sources of danger from infringing on other legal interests.The previous behavior creates a dominant obligation to"not create danger",the main point of judgment is whether the perpetrator actually started the process of infringement of legal interests,which is dominated by the real cause of the result.General non-rescue behavior that does not create danger and has no special obligation does not constitute a crime.
刊 名 刑法论丛
年,卷(期): 2023, 76(4)
机标分类号: D923.8 C912.8 G40-058
在线出版日期: 2026年10月12日