军事知识服务平台
死刑继续削减的体系化进路
Systematic Approach to Further Reduction of the Death Penalty:Reflections under the Perspective of Re-codification of Criminal Law
摘要 在《民法典》颁行之后,我国刑法也面临"再法典化"的任务,其中必然会涉及死刑继续削减的问题.经过《刑法修正案(八)》和《刑法修正案(九)》两次削减死刑,现存的死刑罪名均较为严重,继续沿袭"个罪整体取消"的进路已不可行.为此,需要在刑法"再法典化"的整体性框架之下,从实现罪刑体系均衡性和协调性的向度展开思考,以尽可能削减不必要的死刑配置.一方面,从实现个罪内部刑罚配置均衡性的角度出发,可以考虑取消选择性罪名中运输毒品罪、拐卖妇女罪和战时掠夺居民财物罪的死刑配置,以及取消相关危害公共安全罪、强奸罪和抢劫罪中某些加重情节的死刑配置.另一方面,从实现罪种间刑罚配置协调性的角度出发,可以在对侵犯同类或相似法益的犯罪进行横向比较的基础上,取消盗窃、抢夺类特殊犯罪、贪污罪和军人叛逃罪的死刑配置.总体而言,现阶段对死刑的削减应服务于整体罪刑体系的优化,并兼顾实践可行性.
Abstract:
Following the promulgation of the Civil Code,China's criminal law is also faced with the task of"re-codification",which inevitably involves the further reduction of the death penalty.After the reductions made by the Amendment(Ⅷ)and Amendment(Ⅸ)to the Criminal Law,the remaining capital offenses are relatively severe,making the approach of"wholesale abolition of individual crimes"unfeasible.It's imperative to think within the overarching framework of criminal law re-codification from the perspective of achieving a balanced and harmonized crime-punishment system to minimize unnecessary death penalty provisions.On one hand,considering the balance within individual crime punishment provisions,it's suggested to abolish the death penalty for selective offenses like transporting drugs,abducting and trafficking women,and plundering the property of the residents during the war,as well as certain aggravated circumstances in crimes of endangering public security,rape offense,and the crime of robbery.On the other hand,to harmonize the punishment provisions across different types of crimes,a horizontal comparison of crimes infringing similar or the same legal interests could lead to the abolition of the death penalty for specific crimes like theft,robbery,graft,and military defection.Overall,the current reduction of the death penalty should serve to optimize the overall crime-punishment system while considering practical feasibility.
刊 名 刑法论丛
年,卷(期): 2023, 76(4)
机标分类号: D923 G641 D630.1
在线出版日期: 2026年10月12日
基金项目: 19BFX068:国家社会科学基金,