滥用职权行为不法的分解与认定
Decomposition and Determination of Physical Illegality of Abuse of Power
摘要
滥用职权的行为不法类型一直未被完整揭露,其包含的过失不作为不法一直被忽视,且在实践中常与因果关系规范评价相混同.滥用职权的行为不法是一类特殊的混合行为不法构造.滥用职权行为人在主观心态上经历了从故意到过失的动态发展过程.相应地,滥用职权的行为不法也可以被分解为存在论层面的故意作为与规范论层面的过失不作为两种行为不法样态.在认定混合的行为不法是否成立时,可能出现风险判定对象相混淆、具体认定方式不明确的困境.对此,可以依据滥用职权行为人的风险意识内容划定故意作为创设的风险范围,以此区分故意作为与过失不作为所各自创设的风险内容.其中,故意作为不法可以依据行为人具备风险意识而径直肯定;而过失不作为不法的认定则可能要采取合义务替代行为假设来检验义务违反之规范关联,并采用风险显著升高的检验标准.通过分解滥用职权的行为不法,可以反思故意与过失之间的关系,二者并非对立关系而是层级关系.
The illegal types of abuse of power have not been fully exposed.In judicial practice,there is a phenomenon,which refers to the mistaking mixture about the part of the analysis of negligent omission that included in the determination in abuse of power,and the evaluation of causal relationship norms.The act of abusing power is a special type of illegal construction.The perpetrators' subjective mentality have experienced a dynamic development change from intentional to negligent.Correspondingly,the act of abusing power can also be decomposed into two types of illegal behavior:intentional commission at the ontological level and negligent omission at the normative level.In the actual determination of illegality,there may be difficulties in distinguishing the objects of the determination and clearing methods of determination.In this regard,based on the risk awareness of the perpetrators,the scope of risk created by intentional act and negligent omission can be discriminated,in order to clarify the objects of illegal identification.Among them,the illegality of intentional commission can be directly affirmed based on the actor's risk awareness;while the determination of negligent omission requires adopting the assumption of obligated and substituted behavior to test the normative correlation of obligation violation,and adopting a significantly higher risk test standard.By decomposing the illegality of abusing power,we can consider the relationship between intention and negligence,which is not an opposition but a hierarchical relationship.
年,卷(期):
2023, 76(4)
机标分类号:
D924.1
F270
D63
在线出版日期:
2026年10月12日
基金项目:
:中国人民大学拔尖创新人才培育资助计划,