摘要
精神障碍者的刑事责任是各国刑法和刑法理论所关注的一个领域.我国刑法中的"精神病"即当代精神医学上的"精神障碍"("精神疾病"),包括精神病性精神障碍和非精神病性精神障碍.关于精神障碍者刑事责任能力的判断,当代各国刑法和理论的通说是采生物学与心理学相结合的混合标准,以及该标准中丧失辨认能力或者控制能力的择一制,这也是我国刑法和理论的主张.关于精神障碍者刑事责任能力的等级划分,当代各国刑法中主要有两分制与三分制之别,后者更为合理.我国刑法则经过了从两分制到三分制的发展道路,现行刑法典将精神障碍者划分为完全刑事责任能力、完全无刑事责任能力和限制刑事责任能力三类,相应地适用完全刑事责任、完全无刑事责任和限制(减轻)刑事责任三种刑事责任原则,并对限制刑事责任能力的精神障碍人配置得减制的刑罚处罚原则.加强比较研究并注意吸收司法精神病学等相关学科的新成果,对这一领域的进步特别重要.
The criminal responsibility of individuals with mental disorders is an area of focus in the criminal laws and legal theories of various countries.In Chinese criminal law,"mental illness"corresponds to the contemporary psychiatric term"mental disorder"("mental disease"),which includes both psychotic and non-psychotic disorders.Regarding the assessment of criminal responsibility for individuals with mental disorders,the prevailing view in contemporary criminal law and theory is to adopt a mixed standard that combines biological and psychological factors,along with an option of either loss of the ability to recognize or the ability to control,which is also the stance of Chinese criminal law and theory.In terms of the classification of criminal responsibility levels for individuals with mental disorders,contemporary criminal laws mainly differentiate between a two-tier system and a three-tier system,with the latter being more reasonable.Chinese criminal law has developed from a two-tier system to a three-tier system,with the current criminal code categorizing individuals with mental disorders into three types:those with full criminal responsibility,those with complete lack of criminal responsibility,and those with limited criminal responsibility.Accordingly,it applies the principles of full criminal responsibility,complete lack of criminal responsibility,and limited(mitigated)criminal responsibility,and establishes a principle of reduced penalties for individuals with limited criminal responsibility due to mental disorders.Strengthening comparative research and paying attention to the incorporation of new findings from related disciplines such as forensic psychiatry is particularly important for progress in this field.