比较视域下的诽谤罪的价值构造
The Value Construction of Defamation from a Comparative Perspective
摘要
互联网使诽谤罪出现了由民事侵权走向刑事犯罪的新态势,但在我国刑法重罪体系下,网络诽谤犯罪进入司法程序存在实践方面的困难.德国、日本、韩国等国家刑法构建了保护名誉与言论自由博弈之价值结构,与我国立法和司法实践不相符合,不宜借鉴.我国应坚持人格权保护作为"诽谤罪"的价值结构,应当持最严格的司法审查标准,严格诽谤罪的入罪标准,多数情况下作为民事侵权纠纷来处理,程序上以自诉为原则,公诉诽谤行为只能是国家的最后手段.可引入惩罚性赔偿,建立多元化纠纷解决机制,高效化解侵犯他人的人格和名誉而引发的纠纷.
The Internet makes the crime of defamation appear a new trend from civil tort to criminal offence.However,within the non-misdemeanor system of China,online defamation crimes encounter practical difficulties in judicial proceedings.The criminal law of Germany,Japan,Republic of Korea and other countries has constructed the value structure of the game between the protection of reputation and freedom of speech,which is not in line with China's legislative and judicial practice and should not be used for reference.Our country should insist on the protection of personality right as the value structure of"libel",should hold the strictest standard of judicial review,strict standard of conviction of libel,in most cases as a civil tort dispute to deal with,the procedure is based on the principle of private prosecution,public prosecution of libel can only be the last resort of the state.We can introduce punitive damages and establish a diversified dispute resolution mechanism to effectively resolve disputes caused by infringement of other people's personality and reputation.
年,卷(期):
2023, 76(4)
机标分类号:
D925.1
F271
G640
在线出版日期:
2026年10月12日
基金项目:
GJ2021B03:最高人民检察院重点课题,