军事知识服务平台
涉轻罪集体法益犯罪之规制路径:沟通式刑罚观的引入
The Regulation Path of Collective Interest Crime Involving Misdemeanors:The Introduction of Communicative Penalty View
摘要 随着轻罪时代的到来,轻罪治理成为我国亟须解决的难题.在轻罪外延中,涉轻罪集体法益犯罪是一类典型的犯罪,其呈现出立法与司法层面的双重扩张,为刑事司法带来了全新挑战.在面对涉轻罪集体法益犯罪时,传统的报应主义和预防主义刑罚观皆有不足,难以有效应对,实现刑罚观之革新势在必行.沟通式刑罚观是由英国刑法学家安东尼·达夫提出的刑罚观念,它能够满足我国轻罪治理的需求,并与我国现行司法制度存在契合点,同时与我国的"恤刑"传统具备内在契合性.作为刑罚沟通的见证者,社会公众具备与涉轻罪集体法益犯罪人进行沟通的意愿.治理涉轻罪集体法益犯罪的最终目的是维系社群利益的完整性,而非一味强调惩罚.具体来说,集体法益可分为纯正的集体法益与不纯正的集体法益,部分侵犯纯正集体法益的行为以及侵犯不纯正集体法益的行为属于结果可视化犯罪,对此应当分别采取法益填补与沟通和解的方式处理.而对于结果不可视化的纯正集体法益犯罪,司法机关可以要求犯罪人采用刑罚置换的方式,切实增进社群利益.
Abstract:
In the era of misdemeanor,the regulation of misdemeanor has become an urgent problem in our country.In the extension of misdemeanors,the collective legal interest crime involving misdemeanors is a typical kind of crime,which presents the double expansion of legislation and judicature,and brings new challenges to criminal justice.In the face of collective legal interest crimes involving minor crimes,the traditional retributivism and the preventative penalty view are both inadequate and difficult to deal with effectively,so it is imperative to reform the penalty view.The communication penalty view is a penalty concept put forward by Anthony Duff,a British criminal jurist.It can meet the needs of the management of misdemeanors in our country,and it is in accord with our current judicial system.At the same time,it has an internal correspondence with our tradition of"lenient punishment".As the witness of penalty communication,the public has the will to communicate with the criminal involved in misdemeanor collective legal interests.The ultimate goal of managing misdemeanor-related collective legal interest crimes is to maintain the integrity of community interests,rather than blindly emphasize punishment.To be specific,collective legal interests can be divided into pure collective legal interests and impure collective legal interests,and partial infringement of pure collective legal interests and infringement of impure collective legal interests belong to visualized crimes,which should be dealt with by means of legal interests filling and communication and reconciliation respectively.And for the pure collective legal interest crime whose result is not visible,the judicial organ can require the criminal to adopt the way of penalty replacement to effectively enhance the interests of the community.
刊 名 刑法论丛
年,卷(期): 2023, 76(4)
机标分类号: D924 F239 D630
在线出版日期: 2026年10月12日
基金项目: 24CFX087:国家社会科学基金,