The Legal Logic and Institutional Framework for Ecological Interest Balance under the Perspective of New-Quality Productivity
摘要
本文从法学和生态哲学的角度出发探讨新质生产力与生态利益衡平的关系.首先,在明确什么是"新质生产力"的生态属性、"生态利益平衡"的权利内核的基础上,发现两者之间存在一种关于生产力更新换代以及生产方式改变之间的"建设性张力".其次,在此视角下阐述法理逻辑发生的变化有四个方面:价值取向由"人本位"转变为"生命共同体",权利结构由"以经济自由为主导"变为"生态环境权益并重",公平理念由"交换正义"转变为"分配正义与矫正正义相结合",管理模式由"命令控制型"转变为"多方参与型".但是,这种转变也带来一些问题,如法律法规不健全、各方利益冲突严重、技术和理性之间的矛盾、世界范围内生态治理赤字等问题.最后,本文主张从"整体系统观"的角度出发,在立法上对生态系统本体论进行法律表达,在制度上探索多元共治的新路径,在立法上强化和完善绿色产权的激励和制约,在国际上促进生态法治话语的包容性重塑,为中国生态法治文明建设提供一套完整的解决方案.
New-quality productivity is an innovation-driven advanced productive force that embodies green development through high technology,efficiency,and quality.To a certain extent,it can address the zero-sum game between ecological and e-conomic interests in traditional productivity models.However,technological innovation and the upgrading of production factors do not spontaneously lead to a reasonable distribution of benefits;they may even further exacerbate the occupation of ecological re-sources,the transfer of environmental pollution,and the deprivation of green rights.From the perspectives of law and ecological philosophy,this study explores the relationship between new-quality productivity and the balance of ecological interests.First,on the basis of clarifying the ecological attributes of"new-quality productivity"and the rights core of"ecological interest balance,"it identifies a"constructive tension"between the two regarding productivity upgrades and changes in production methods.Second,from this perspective,four changes in legal logic are elaborated:the value orientation shifts from"human-centeredness"to a"community of life";the rights structure shifts from"economic freedom dominance"to"equal emphasis on ecological and environ-mental rights and interests";the concept of fairness shifts from"exchange justice"to"a combination of distributive justice and corrective justice";and the management model shifts from"command-and-control"to"multi-stakeholder participation."However,these transformations also bring challenges,such as inadequate laws and regulations,intense conflicts among various stakeholders,tensions between technology and rationality,and global deficits in ecological governance.Finally,this study advo-cates adopting a"holistic systems perspective"to legally articulate ecosystem ontology in legislation,explore new paths of multi-stakeholder co-governance in institutional design,strengthen and improve the incentives and constraints of green property rights,and promote the inclusive reshaping of international discourse on ecological rule of law,thereby providing a comprehensive solution for the construction of China's ecological legal civilization.