军事知识服务平台
智能体自主决策的责任解构与数字法治规制范式重塑
Deconstruction of Autonomous Decision-Making Responsibilities in Intelligent Agents and Reconfiguration of Digital Legal Governance Paradigms
摘要 本文从智能体自主作出决定所带来的责任难题出发,探讨如何实现对数字法治进行重构.主要批评目前立法上存在的三大问题:人的责任逃避机制、算法黑箱造成原因力缺失以及编码控制带来的合法性和技术民粹主义.从认知科学、控制论以及分布式责任伦理角度出发,重新审视责任分担问题,提出了"功能—情境"的两步式归责思路以及基于"过程性控制力"的动态责任分担方式.在此基础上,以自动驾驶、智能投顾及生成式 AI 内容审核为例,说明责任分解思想具有适用性,进一步提出从"事后惩罚"到"全过程管理"数字化法治新模式,即算法影响评估、问责沙盒和可争议性设计等一系列制度措施.
Abstract:
This study attempts to explore how to reconstruct digital legal governance from the perspective of responsibility challen-ges posed by autonomous decision-making of intelligent agents.It critically examines three major legislative shortcomings:mecha-nisms enabling human accountability avoidance,the lack of causal accountability due to algorithmic black boxes,and legitimacy is-sues arising from code control and technological populism.Drawing on cognitive science,cybernetics,and distributed responsibility ethics,this study re-examines the issue of responsibility allocation and proposes a"function-context"two-step attribution framework as well as a dynamic responsibility-sharing mechanism based on"processual control."On this basis,taking autono-mous driving,robo-advisors,and generative AI content moderation as examples,this paper demonstrates the applicability of the deconstruction approach,and further proposes a new digital governance model shifting from"ex post punishment"to"full-process management",encompassing a series of institutional measures such as algorithmic impact assessments,accountability sandboxes,and contestability design.