李格尔与黑格尔的艺术史学之比较
A Comparison of Riegl and Hegel in Art Historiography
摘要
李格尔和黑格尔都是西方艺术史学史上的重要人物.贡布里希认为李格尔的艺术史学"用心理学体系来解释黑格尔体系",是"没有形而上学的黑格尔主义",此评述更多是从前述两人的艺术史学之间的深刻渊源关系出发作出的.但笔者认为,李格尔对艺术史学的贡献,恰恰在于他对黑格尔将艺术史统一到哲学体系的做法作出了突破.从艺术史发展的动力、艺术史演进的图式、艺术史研究的方法三方面,可以分析李格尔和黑格尔的艺术史思想之间的联系与断裂.
Both Riegl and Hegel are significant figures in the history of Western art historiography.Gombrich regarded Riegl's art historiography as"explaining the Hegelian system through a psychological system"and as"Hegelianism without metaphysics".This assessment is largely formulated from the profound theoretical connections between their respective approaches to art historiography.However,the author argues that Riegl's contribution to art historiography lies precisely in his breakthrough in Hegel's integration of art history into philosophical system.The continuities and ruptures between Riegl's and Hegel's ideas on art history can be analyzed from three dimensions:the driving force of the development of art history,the schema of art historical evolution,and the methodologies employed in art history research.
年,卷(期):
2026, (5)
机标分类号:
J0
B5
B222
在线出版日期:
2026年9月21日
基金项目:
19YJA760025:教育部人文社会科学研究项目,