摘要
对一个公平且正义的人工智能(AI)的需求经常和理解人工智能本身的可能性相关,或者说,和将一个不透明的盒子变成一个尽可能可观察的玻璃盒子的可能性相关.然而,透明性和可解释性属于技术领域和科学哲学的讨论范围,从而很大程度上和人工智能的伦理学和认识论是割裂的.为了避免这一点,我们提出了一个整体性的方法,此方法基于以下观念:一个玻璃盒型的认识论需要明确考虑如何在从设计、实现到使用和评估的整个过程的许多关键阶段中整合价值和其他规范性上的考虑,例如跨部门脆弱性(intersectoral vulnerabilities).为了联系人工智能的伦理学和认识论,我们进行了两个焦点转换.其一,我们从对人工智能系统输出的信任转向了对导致这一输出的过程的信任.其二,我们从专家评估转向了更具包容性的评估策略,致力于同时帮助专家和非专家的评估.这两个转换将共同产生一个在专家和非专家询问人工智能系统的认识论和伦理学相关方面的问题时都有用的框架.我们将这个框架命名为"认识论兼伦理"(epistemology-cum-ethics),用以表示两个方面同样重要.我们从利于设计者的角度去开发这个框架:为了将价值内化于设计、实现、使用和评估一个人工智能系统的整个过程,并且在这一系统中,(认知的和非认知的)价值都在每一阶段被明确考虑且可被每一个主要参与者随时检查——我们怎样去创造这样的条件.
The need for fair and just AI is often related to the possibility of understand-ing AI itself,in other words,of turning an opaque box into a glass box,as inspectable as possible.Transparency and explainability,however,pertain to the technical domain and to philosophy of science,thus leaving the ethics and epistemology of AI largely disconnected.To remedy this,we propose an integrated approach premised on the idea that a glass-box episte-mology should explicitly consider how to incorporate values and other normative considera-tions,such as intersectoral vulnerabilities,at critical stages of the whole process from design and implementation to use and assessment.To connect ethics and epistemology of AI,we per-form a double shift of focus.First,we move from trusting the output of an AI system to trust-ing the process that leads to the outcome.Second,we move from expert assessment to more inclusive assessment strategies,aiming to facilitate expert and non-expert assessment.Togeth-er,these two moves yield a framework usable for experts and non-experts when they inquire into relevant epistemological and ethical aspects of AI systems.We dub our framework'epis-temology-cum-ethics'to signal the equal importance of both aspects.We develop it from the vantage point of the designers:how to create the conditions to internalize values into the whole process of design,implementation,use,and assessment of an AI system,in which values(epistemic and non-epistemic)are explicitly considered at each stage and inspectable by every salient actor involved at any moment.