摘要
评估人工智能的核心难点之一在于人们倾向于将之拟人化.当我们将人类的道德活动模式应用于人工智能时,问题会变得尤为棘手.例如,欧盟委员会的人工智能高级专家组主张,我们应当与人工智能建立一种信任关系,并培养值得信任的人工智能.信任是人类关系中最重要、具有决定意义的行为之一,因此,"人工智能应当被信任"这一主张是极为严肃的论断.本文将论证:按照当今最为广泛使用的"信任"定义,人工智能并不具备可被信任的能力,因为它不具备情感状态,也不能对自身行为承担责任——而这恰恰是关于信任的情感论和规范论的基本要求.虽然人工智能满足关于信任的理性论的全部条件,但本文主张这并非真正的信任,而只是一种信赖.归根结底,即使是像人工智能这样复杂的机器,也不应被视为值得信任的主体,因为这种做法会贬损人际信任的价值、将人工智能拟人化,并转移这些系统的开发者与使用者的责任.
One of the main difficulties in assessing artificial intelligence(AI)is the tendency for people to anthropomorphise it.This becomes particularly problematic when we attach human moral activities to AI.For example,the European Commission's High-level Expert Group on AI(HLEG)have adopted the position that we should establish a relationship of trust with AI and should cultivate trustworthy AI.Trust is one of the most important and defining activities in human relationships,so proposing that AI should be trusted,is a very serious claim.This paper will show that AI cannot be something that has the capacity to be trusted according to the most prevalent definitions of trust because it does not possess emotive states or can be held responsible for their actions—requirements of the affective and normative accounts of trust.While AI meets all of the requirements of the rational account of trust,it will be shown that this is not actually a type of trust at all,but is instead,a form of reliance.Ultimately,even complex machines such as AI should not be viewed as trustworthy as this undermines the value of interpersonal trust,anthropomorphises AI,and diverts responsibility from those de-veloping and using them.