军事知识服务平台
责任空缺:由来已久,不可避免,不构成挑战
Responsibility Gap:Not New,Inevitable,Unproblematic
摘要 谁应该为人工智能或依赖人工智能的机器或系统造成的伤害负责?鉴于当前的人工智能既无意识也无感知能力,尚不清楚人工智能本身是否应对上述伤害负责.但是,由于人工智能的行为独立于其开发者或使用者,因此也不清楚开发者或使用者是否应对伤害负责.这就产生了所谓的"责任空缺"(responsibility gap)的情况,即人工智能造成了伤害,却无人对伤害负责.当前文献讨论的两个核心问题是:责任空缺是否存在?如果存在,它是否构成道德上反对开发或使用人工智能的理由?一些作者认为责任空缺存在,并且构成道德上的挑战;而另一些作者则认为,责任空缺不存在.在本文中,我捍卫一个新颖的立场.首先,我认为当前的人工智能并未产生一种旧有技术所不具备的、关于责任的新担忧.其次,我认为责任空缺确实存在,但它不构成挑战.
Abstract:
Who is responsible for a harm caused by AI,or a machine or system that relies on artifi-cial intelligence?Given that current AI is neither conscious nor sentient,it's unclear that AI itself is responsible for it.But given that AI acts independently of its developer or user,it's al-so unclearthat the developer or user is responsible for the harm.This gives rise to the so-called responsibility gap:cases where AI causes a harm,but no one is responsible for it.Two cen-tral questions in the literature are whether responsibility gaps exist,and if yes,whether they're morally problematic in a way that counts against developing or using AI.While some authors argue that responsibility gaps exist,and they're morally problematic,some argue that they don't exist.In this paper,I defend a novel position.First,I argue that current AI doesn't generate a new kind of concern about responsibility that the older technologies don't.Then,I argue that responsibility gaps exist but they're unproblematic.
刊 名 应用伦理
年,卷(期): 2026, 3(1)
机标分类号: D914 R169 TP391
在线出版日期: 2026年5月14日