生物道德增强何以不可接受?
Why is Moral Bio-Enhancement Unacceptable?
摘要
生物道德增强是指运用生物医疗等技术来提升人的道德能力.其倡导者道格拉斯持有一种偏弱的生物道德增强立场,即至少在一些情况下生物道德增强是道德上可接受的.本文集中考察了道格拉斯立足于"反道德情感"的积极论证以及他基于动机、手段和后果回应反驳观点的消极论证,发现其无法为生物道德增强提供令人满意的辩护.一方面,道格拉斯的积极论证缺乏足够的理论依据,不仅无法回应来自技术有效性方面的疑问,也难以准确界定"反道德情感"的范围.另一方面,消极论证不仅曲解了反驳意见,还回避了关键质疑,因此仍然会导致搭便车和道德衰退等道德后果.因此,道格拉斯的辩护无法成立,弱的生物道德增强是不可接受的.
Moral bioenhancement refers to the use of biomedical technologies to aug-ment human moral capacities.Its proponent Douglas holds a weak position on moral bioen-hancement,arguing that it is morally acceptable at least in certain circumstances.This paper examines Douglas's affirmative argument grounded in"anti-moral sentiments"and his nega-tive argument responding to objections based on motives,means,and consequences.It finds that his defense fails to provide a satisfactory justification for moral bioenhancement.On the one hand,Douglas's affirmative argument lacks sufficient theoretical grounding.It not only fails to address questions regarding technological efficacy but also struggles to precisely define the scope of"anti-moral sentiments."On the other hand,his negative argument not only misrepresents counterarguments but also evades crucial critiques,thereby still leading to mor-al consequences such as free-riding and moral decline.Consequently,Douglas's defense fails,and weak moral bioenhancement is unacceptable.
年,卷(期):
2026, 3(1)
机标分类号:
B82-02
G41
G641
在线出版日期:
2026年5月14日