军事知识服务平台
人工智能会否改变部分专利法范式?
Will Artificial Intelligence Change Some Patent Law Paradigms?
摘要 在简要介绍人工智能工具后,作者通过三项被科学作家完全归因于人工智能的重要研究成果,结合原始研究报告,探讨了此类报道的准确性.作者介绍了欧洲、日本、中国和美国专利局的实践,这些机构原则上都授予与人工智能相关的发明专利.随后,文章对学术界关于现有专利法范式是否能够应对人工智能技术挑战的质疑进行了批判性反思.文章以广为人知的"DABUS"专利申请案为例,论述了主张人工智能自主发明的观点存在的纰漏,并指出现有法律体系的缺陷,同时提出了改善措施,例如更有效地确定现有技术状态并评估人工智能相关发明的创造性要求.根据全球主要专利局的实践及其主要用户对该实践的理解和评估,作者认为,在人工智能技术的影响下,既定的专利法范式将经历一定的进化性调整,但其核心实质不会发生改变.最后,文章对欧盟计划通过一项专门处理人工智能相关发明复杂专利问题的法规草案提出了批判性评论.
Abstract:
After a brief introduction into the tools of artificial intelligence(AI),the author uses three important research achievements attributed by science writers entirely to the AI to examine the correctness of such reporting in the light of the original research reports.The author presents the practice of the EPO,JPO,SIPO and USPTO,which all in principle grant patents for AI-related inven-tions.A critical reflection on the academic debate questioning the ability of the es-tablished patent law paradigms to master the challenges of the AI technology fol-lows.The facts of the broadly publicised"DABUS"patent applications serve to demonstrate the weakness of the assertion that AI autonomously invented the claimed inventions and to point to the deficiencies of the system and suggest meas-ures,for example,to adequately determine the prior art,and assess the inventive step requirement for AI-related inventions.In line with the practice of the leading patent offices of the world,the understanding and assessment of that practice by its main users,the author believes that under the impact of the AI technology,the settled patent law paradigms will undergo certain evolutionary adaptations,but will not change as to their substance.Finally,the article critically comments on the EU plans to adopt a regulation,which would specifically deal with all complex aspects of patenting AI-related inventions.