军事知识服务平台
德国刑法学中的主观正当化要素必要性论争
摘要 基于构成要件符合性与违法性的区分,主观正当化要素的概念仅限于阻却违法性的主观要素而不涉及阻却构成要件符合性的主观要素,包括但不限于防卫意思、避险意思.在犯罪论体系发展史上,主观正当化要素与主观不法要素相伴生,是客观主义与主观主义不法理论的试金石.随着主观不法观念的形成与发展,纯粹客观的不法理论发生体系性动摇,否定主观正当化要素必要性的客观主义观点逐渐成为少数说.当前,德国刑法学界的主流观点对主观正当化要素必要性予以肯定,从实定法、二阶层犯罪论构造、目的行为论等进路展开论证,为主观正当化要素的具体内容及其关联法律效果的分析提供了理论基础.
Abstract:
Based on the distinction between compliance with constitutive ele-ments and unlawfulness,the concept of subjective justificatory elements is confined to those subjective factors that preclude unlawfulness,without involving those that negate compliance with constitutive elements.These include,but are not limited to,subjective conditions of defense or necessity.In the historical development of the criminal system,subjective justificatory elements have coexisted with subjective wrongfulness elements,serving as a reference point for objective and subjective theories of wrongfulness.With the development of the concept of subjec-tive wrongfulness,purely objective theories of wrongfulness have undergone sys-temic challenges,and the objective perspective that denies subjective justificatory elements has gradually become a minority view.At present,the majority view in German criminal law scholarship supports the necessity of subjective justificatory elements.Scholars adopt various approaches,including positive law,the two-level criminal system,the theory of final acts,and others,among additional theoretical perspectives,to establish a foundation for analyzing the specific content of subjective justificatory elements and their associated legal effects.
年,卷(期): 2024, (2)
机标分类号: D914 G25 F270
在线出版日期: 2026年8月17日
基金项目: :国家建设高水平大学公派研究生项目,