军事知识服务平台
法治吸纳政治:"重要数据"原论
Rule-of-Law's Absorption of Politics:An Original Theory of the Important Data
摘要 尽管"重要数据"系我国数据法中具有原创性与基础性的标识性概念,但却长期陷入内涵和外延混沌的困境.明晰类型与明晰要件这两种具体化路径,在可预期性与可操作性上均告不足.这是因为,既有实践并未认识到重要数据的不确定性根源于其政治性,因而亟待通过"法治吸纳政治"的理论框架重塑我国数据领域政治与法的关系,从而将重要数据这一不确定概念转化为容纳对话与分歧的框架秩序.循此,一方面应借法律解释的制度拘束细化重要数据的"属性要件"与"风险要件",另一方面应构造重要数据程序主义,以参与、透明、科学、中立、束缚、动态六原则优化重要数据的动态生成机制,两者协同共振,最终形成安定性与正当性兼备的重要数据概念.
Abstract:
While"important data"stands as an identifying concept in Chinese data law that is at once original and foundational,it has long been trapped in a predicament of ambiguity regarding both its intension and extension.The two paths of concretization—clarifying its types and clarifying its elements—prove inadequate along both the dimensions of predictability and operability.The reason lies in the fact that existing practice has yet to recognize that the indeterminacy of important data is rooted in its political nature.It is therefore imperative to reconstruct the relationship between politics and law in China through the theoretical framework of"the rule of law's absorption of politics,"so as to transform this indeterminate concept into a framework order that accommodates both dialogue and dissent.Guided by this framework,the institutional constraints of legal interpretation should,on the one hand,be drawn upon to elaborate the"attribute elements"and"risk elements"of important data;on the other hand,a proceduralism of important data should be constructed,deploying the six principles of participation,transparency,scientific rigor,neutrality,bindingness,and dynamism to refine its dynamic generation mechanism.The two operate in concert,ultimately yielding a concept of important data that is at once certain(Rechtssicherheit)and legitimate.
刊 名 政法论丛 PKU
年,卷(期): 2026, (5)
分类号: DF37
机标分类号: D922.52 A849.1 K901
在线出版日期: 2026年10月27日
基金项目: 22BFX080:国家社会科学基金24VRC055:国家社会科学基金,