Legal Governance of AIGC:From the Creation of Private Rights to Contract-Led Governance
摘要
围绕AIGC的法律性质,当前主流研究延续着"私权赋权"的理论路径.然而,该路径预设AIGC与既有著作权客体同构,忽视了其技术本质、法律关系与制度功能的系统性变革.从技术本质看,AIGC是以Token为符号的算力输出结果,并非人类智力创作;从法律关系看,使用者与服务提供者之间形成以获取算力技术成果为目的的持续性技术服务合同关系;从制度功能看,AIGC法律治理应服务于产业促进与国家战略利益.在法哲学层面,劳动理论、人格理论与激励理论均无法为AIGC的私权赋权提供正当性依据.我国应转向"合同主导"路径,以合同法为核心确立权利归属与利益分配规则,辅以侵权责任、反不正当竞争与公法规制,构建兼顾私权保障、产业创新与国家利益的协同治理体系.
With regard to the legal nature of AIGC,mainstream scholarship continues to follow the theoretical path of private right creation.This approach,however,presupposes that AIGC is structurally analogous to existing copyright subject matter and overlooks systemic transformations in its technical essence,legal relationships and institutional functions.Technically,AIGC is a computational output composed of tokens,not a product of human intellectual creation.In legal terms,the relationship between users and service providers stems from a continuing technical service contract aimed at obtaining such outputs.From a functional perspective,the governance of AIGC should be oriented toward industrial development and national strategic interests.From a legal philosophical standpoint,the labor theory,personality theory and incentive theory can not provide a sound justification for conferring private rights upon AIGC.China should therefore shift toward a contract-led path.Contract law should serve as the core instrument for establishing rules on rights ownership and benefit allocation,supplemented by tort liability,unfair competition law and public law regulation.This would establish a coordinated governance system that balances private rights protection,industrial innovation and national interests.