军事知识服务平台
算法决策中劳动者拒绝权的程序性控制功能
The Procedural Control Function of Workers' Right to Refuse in Algorithmic Decision-Making
摘要 算法管理已全面渗透进劳动过程,劳动者的工作安排与职业存续日益由算法系统决定.现行法上的自动化决策拒绝权在权力从属性结构中难以运转,其功能需要从消极阻断重新定位为程序性控制装置,经由说明义务、人工审查与人工重新决策,将算法黑箱还原为可审查的决策程序.但算法管理以持续控制替代离散决策,使决策概念失去锚点;从属性使劳动者因恐惧不利对待而不敢行权;人工审查因主体不独立而流于形式.激活程序性控制功能,需要在劳动法层面确立法定告知义务与行权安全保障机制,通过裁判积累逐步形成人工审查的实质标准,并以集体劳动权的嵌入弥补个体的结构性弱势.
Abstract:
Algorithmic management has thoroughly permeated the labor process,with workers' job assignments and employment continuity increasingly determined by algorithmic systems.The existing statutory right to refuse automated decision-making fails to function within the subordinate structure of employment relationships,and its role needs to be repositioned from passive blocking to a procedural control mechanism.Through explanation obligations,human review,and human re-decision-making,this mechanism aims to render the algorithmic black box into a reviewable decision-making procedure.However,algorithmic management replaces discrete decisions with continuous control,leaving the concept of"decision"without an anchor;subordination deters workers from exercising their rights for fear of adverse treatment;and human review becomes a mere formality due to the lack of independence of reviewers.Activating the procedural control function requires the statutory establishment of notification obligations and safeguard mechanisms for the exercise of rights within the framework of labor law,the gradual development of substantive standards for human review through judicial practice,and the integration of collective labor rights to address the structural vulnerability of individual workers.
刊 名 政法论丛 PKU
年,卷(期): 2026, (5)
分类号: DF47
机标分类号: D913 F336.45 TP391
在线出版日期: 2026年10月27日
基金项目: 25CFX085:国家社会科学基金,