The Operational Boundaries and Procedural Connection of the Procuratorates' Flexible Investigation Power
摘要
检察机关机动侦查权的正当运行有赖于边界的严格划定与程序的顺畅衔接.运行边界层面,"利用职权"要件应作程序法解释,限定于在犯罪中实际发挥作用,并区分直接与间接用权形态;共同犯罪应构建特别并案规则,并以事实同一性与统一侦查为条件,而关联犯罪则依不同管辖机关的法定职能分别处置;检察机关可以利用数字监督模型辅助发现线索,但受目的限制、人工确认与分级核验约束,仅可采取非强制措施,公安机关仍负侦查与必要保全义务.程序衔接层面,原案件以移送方式承继而非撤销,侦查措施与强制措施应分类确立衔接规则,既有证据随案移送并强化合法性审查;管辖基础变动后,区分静态要件与动态要件分别处理.
The proper exercise of the procuratorates' flexible investigation power depends on the strict delimitation of its boundaries and the smooth connection of procedures.At the level of operational boundaries,the element of"taking advantage of official authority"should be interpreted in light of procedural law,confined to authority that actually functions in the commission of the crime,with a distinction drawn between direct and indirect forms of exercising authority.Special rules on consolidated handling should be established for joint crimes,conditioned upon the identity of the facts and the need for unified investigation,whereas related crimes should be disposed of separately in accordance with the statutory functions of the respective authorities having jurisdiction.Procuratorial organs may employ digital supervision models to assist in discovering leads,but such use is subject to purpose limitation,human confirmation,and tiered verification;only non-coercive measures may be taken,and the public security organs remain under the obligation to investigate and to take necessary preservation measures.At the level of procedural connection,the original case is succeeded by way of transfer rather than revocation;connecting rules for investigative measures and coercive measures should be established by category,and the existing evidence is transferred with the case file and subjected to heightened legality review.Where the basis of jurisdiction changes,static elements and dynamic elements should be distinguished and handled separately.