军事知识服务平台
机动侦查权的复合属性辨析与适用机制建构
An Analysis of the Composite Nature of the Power of Mobile Investigation and the Development of Its Application Mechanism
摘要 我国机动侦查权长期低位运行,制度效能未充分释放,根本原因在于法律属性界定不清.从机关性质、目的对象、权力制衡三方面辨析,其表现为结构性独立、工具性本质与动态制衡三重面向,具有"备位侦查"与"刚性监督"并存的二元功能形态.机制建构上,实体层面应以"可能判处五年以上有期徒刑"为"重大犯罪案件"的主要认定基准,辅以行为性质与侦查障碍标准;同时,将"需要由人民检察院直接受理"界定为穷尽监督后的审慎选择,明确设区的市级检察院为主要行使主体.程序层面应规范先行介入与续行介入模式,构建"双重推定规则"降低启动门槛,并配套异议申辩、备案审查等反向制约机制.保障层面需优化检警协作、解耦个人责任,再配置办案资源.
Abstract:
In China,the power of mobile investigation has long been exercised only to a limited extent,and its institutional efficacy has not been fully realized,fundamentally because its legal nature remains unclear.Analyzed from the three perspectives of institutional nature,purpose and object,and checks and balances on power,the power exhibits structural independence,an instrumental essence,and dynamic checks and balances,and has a dual functional configuration in which"subsidiary investigation"coexists with"binding supervision."As to the rules governing its application,at the substantive level,"a possible sentence of fixed-term imprisonment of five years or more"should serve as the principal benchmark for identifying"major criminal cases,"supplemented by the nature of the conduct and impediments to investigation;meanwhile,the requirement that a case"needs to be directly accepted by a people's procuratorate"should be construed as a prudent option of last resort after supervisory measures have been exhausted,with people's procuratorates at the level of cities divided into districts designated as the principal organs for exercising the power.At the procedural level,the modes of early intervention and continued intervention should be standardized,a"dual-presumption rule"should be established to lower the threshold for activation,and countervailing checks,including objection and defense procedures and record-filing review,should be put in place;at the safeguards level,coordination between procuratorates and public security organs should be optimized,individual responsibility should be decoupled,and case-handling resources should be reallocated to further improve the system.
刊 名 政法论丛 PKU
年,卷(期): 2026, (5)
分类号: DF83
机标分类号: D925.1 P631.4 D262
在线出版日期: 2026年10月27日
基金项目: 25YJC820017:教育部人文社会科学研究项目,