摘要
贷款犯罪是普遍存在且容易引发系统性金融风险的金融犯罪类型.现行罪名体系根据贷款犯罪主体间对应关系或沿袭金融体制改革历程而构建,但各罪名的构成要件规定之间的离散性大于整体规制体系的耦合性.贷款犯罪侵害的核心法益应为贷款资金安全,而不应扩张至更宽泛的信贷范畴,且侵害对象主要是银行.对此,应当在辨析法益保护次序的基础上,重新调整贷款犯罪体系.基于核心法益与公私主体专业能力及风险注意义务相匹配的考量,建议废除未明确以贷款资金安全为保护法益的高利转贷罪.在复合法益框架中,骗取贷款罪、贷款诈骗罪同时侵害了具有辅助性、解析性与计量性特征的信用法益,违法发放贷款罪则侵害了相对独立的信任法益.上述法益区分可以合理解释各罪名的成罪事由差异,尤其是在骗取贷款罪立案后偿还欠款可以实现法益的部分或整体修复,进而获得罪责减轻乃至出罪的司法处理,并可出于融资促进的政策需要,在适用中对各罪作充分且妥当的司法限缩.
Loan crimes are a prevalent type of financial offense that can easily trigger systemic financial risks.The current system of crimes is constructed according to the relationship among criminal subjects or the progression of financial system reform.However,the divergence among the constituent elements of these offenses exceeds the coherence of the overall regulatory system.The core legal interest infringed by loan crimes should be the safety of loan funds,rather than extending to the broader scope of credit funds,with banks as the main infringed subject.In this regard,the loan crime system shall be readjusted by clarifying the order of protected legal interests.Based on the consideration of aligning core legal interests with the professional capabilities and risk-related duty of care of public and private entities,it is recommended to abolish the crime of usury loan transfer,which does not explicitly take the safety of loan funds as its protected legal interest.Within the framework of composite legal interests,the crime of fraudulently obtaining loans and the crime of loan fraud simultaneously infringe upon credit legal interests,which possess auxiliary,analytical,and quantitative characteristics.Conversely,the crime of illegally issuing loans infringes upon trust legal interests,which are relatively independent.This distinction can reasonably explain the differences in the constitutive elements of each crime,particularly accounting for the judicial disposition that repaying loans after a case involving fraudulently obtaining loans has been filed can restore part or all of legal interests,thereby resulting in mitigation of criminal liability or even exemption from criminal punishment.Moreover,it enables the appropriately limited application of each crime in light of policies promoting financing.