军事知识服务平台
广州市某三级医院10652例疑似结核病患者病原学阳性检出率的影响因素
Factors influencing detection rate of positive pathogen among 10652 suspected tuberculosis patients in a tertiary hospital of Guangzhou
摘要 目的 探究疑似结核病患者阳性检出率的影响因素,评估肺结核(pulmonary tuberculosis,PTB)和肺外结核(extra-pulmonary tuberculosis,EPTB)的检验效能与患者检测量是否存在不足,为体外诊断(in vitro diagnostic,IVD)产品研发提供参考.方法 选取广州市某三级医院结核病分子诊断项目"结核分枝杆菌核酸定量检测(TB-PCR)"在2018年1月至2022年10月的检测结果进行分析.比较阳性检出率在样本类型(呼吸道来源与非呼吸道来源)、检验频次(1次、2次和≥3次)、统计方式(首诊检验与全检验)及病情严重程度(门诊、普通住院和重症)4种因素作用下的差异情况;分析靶基因IS6110拷贝数分布差异及相关趋势.结果 共纳入呼吸道来源患者8 441例,非呼吸道来源患者2 211例,门诊、普通住院和重症3类患者中,呼吸道来源样本的阳性检出率均显著高于非呼吸道来源样本(χ2=166.175,P<0.001;χ2=52.026,P<0.001;χ2=82.421,P<0.001);检验频次为1次、2次和≥3次的患者分别为6 563例、1 401例和477例,仅在门诊和普通住院2类患者中,3种"检验频次类型"的阳性检出率差异有统计学意义(χ2=48.897,P<0.001;χ2=23.935,P<0.001),重症患者中,则无统计学意义(χ2=5.384,P=0.068);首诊检验统计和全检验统计的患者均为8 441例,门诊、普通住院和重症3类患者中,2种统计方式的阳性检出率差异均无统计学意义(χ2=2.054,P=0.152;χ2=2.086,P=0.149;χ2=2.668,P=0.102);呼吸道与非呼吸道2类来源样本中,3类患者分别为3 752例与1 393例、3 242例与464例、1 447例与354例,在固定条件下(检验频次或统计方式),3类患者的阳性检出率差异均有统计学意义(χ2=307.882,P<0.001;χ2=28.679,P<0.001;χ2=26.574,P<0.001;χ2=325.894,P<0.001;χ2=370.571,P<0.001;χ2=103.216,P<0.001).患者IS6110拷贝数随病情加重而呈显著上升趋势(J-T值=6.792,P<0.001).结论 样本类型、检验频次、病情严重程度均能影响阳性检出率;EPTB的检出率及灵敏度显著低于PTB,需更优质的检验方法;门诊与普通住院2类患者应进行2~3次检验,存在患者检测量不足的现象,增加检验频次对疑似结核病患者尽早确定病因具有重要意义;样本类型和病情严重程度对阳性检出率的影响对IVD产品的研发具有重要指导意义.
Abstract:
Objective Using quantitative nucleic acid testing for Mycobacterium tuberculosis as an effective tool for screening tuberculosis infection,this study examines factors affecting the positive detection rate in suspected TB patients,and evaluates inadequacies in detection efficiency and patient numbers for pulmonary tuberculosis(PTB)and extra-pulmonary tuberculosis(EPTB).It also assesses the impact of these factors on developing in vitro diagnostic(IVD)products.Methods The detection outcomes of the tuberculosis molecular diagnosis initiative in"Quantitative Nucleic Acid Detection for Mycobacterium tuberculosis(TB-PCR)"were systematically analyzed at a hospital from January 2018 to October 2022.The study compared variations in the positive detection rates influenced by four factors:sample type(respiratory vs.non-respiratory sources),test frequency(once,twice,and three times or more),statistical method(initial laboratory tests vs.all laboratory tests),and severity of illness(outpatients,general inpatients,and intensive care unit patients).Additionally,the study examined the differences in distribution of copy numbers and its associated trends of target gene IS6110.Results A total of 8 441 patients with respiratory tract origins and 2 211 patients with non-respiratory tract origins were included in the study.Among outpatients,general inpatients,and intensive care unit patients,the positive detection rate for samples originating from the respiratory tract was significantly higher than that from non-respiratory tract origins(χ2=166.175,P<0.001;χ2=52.026,P<0.001;χ2=82.421,P<0.001).The number of patients with testing frequencies of 1,2,and 3 or more were 6 563,1 401,and 477,respectively.The positive detection rates of the three"test frequency types"demonstrated statistical significance exclusively among outpatients and general inpatients(χ2=48.897,P<0.001;χ2=23.935,P<0.001).However,no statistical significance was observed among intensive care unit patients(χ2=5.384,P=0.068).A total of 8 441 patients were included in the analysis of initial laboratory test and all laboratory test.Among the three types of patients,there was no statistically significant difference in positive detection rates between the two statistical methods(χ2=2.054,P=0.152;χ2=2.086,P=0.149;χ2=2.668,P=0.102);Among the samples from respiratory tract and non-respiratory tract,there were 3 752 cases and 1 393 cases,3 242 cases and 464 cases,1 447 cases and 35 cases among the three types of patients,respectively.Under fixed conditions(test frequency or statistical method),the positive detection rates were statistically significant of the three types of patients(χ2=307.882,P<0.001;χ2=28.679,P<0.001;χ2=26.574,P<0.001;χ2=325.894,P<0.001;χ2=37.571,P<0.001;χ2=103.216,P<0.001);The copy number of IS6110 in the patients exhibited a statistically significant upward trend correlating with the deterioration of their condition(J-T value=6.795,P<0.001).Conclusions The positive detection rate can be influenced by three factors:sample type,testing frequency,and disease severity;The detection rate and sensitivity of EPTB are significantly lower than those of PTB,there is an urgent need for the development of more advanced testing methods.Outpatients and general inpatients should undergo testing a minimum of two to three times,however,there is an observed issue of inadequate testing among patients.Increasing the testing frequency is crucial for individuals suspected of tuberculosis;The influence of sample type and illness severity on the positive detection rate holds substantial significance for guiding the research and development of IVD products.
刊 名 中国热带医学 ISTICPKU
年,卷(期): 2026, 26(9)
机标分类号: R781.05 R563.1 R378
在线出版日期: 2026年9月24日
基金项目: 2025A03J3779:广州市科技计划市校(院)企联合资助项目,