军事知识服务平台
国产双刃双气路玻璃体切割头稳定性与切割效率的研究
A study on the stability and cutting efficiency of a domestically produced dual-blade, dual-port vitrectomy probe
摘要 目的:评估国产S型双刃双气路玻璃体切割头(简称"玻切头")在玻璃体切割手术(PPV)中的稳定性与切割效率。方法:前瞻性、随机对照、非劣效性、多中心临床试验研究。于2025年8月在厦门眼科中心、北京大学人民医院眼科、北京大学国际医院眼科行PPV治疗的患者120例纳入研究。依据切割频率及器械来源分为4组:10 k cpm国产S型玻切头(S-玻切头)组、10 k cpm进口A型玻切头(A-玻切头)组、20 k cpm S-玻切头组、20 k cpm A-玻切头组,每组各30例。S-玻切头在10 k cpm和20 k cpm频率下均采用双刃双气路设计;A-玻切头在10 k cpm频率下为单刃设计,20 k cpm频率下为双刃设计。对比观察两组在切割效率、安全性(医源性视网膜裂孔发生率)及设备稳定性(气泡产生、频率与负压变化、次品检出)方面的差异。组间比较采用 χ2检验。 结果:因20 k cpm S-玻切头组1例患者数据缺失,最终纳入统计分析119例,其中S-玻切头组59例(10 k cpm 30例,20 k cpm 29例),A-玻切头组60例(10 k cpm、20 k cpm各30例)。两组在10 k cpm及20 k cpm条件下,患者年龄、性别构成比、眼别、是否联合白内障手术、麻醉方式、疾病分类、增生性玻璃体视网膜病变情况、增生型糖尿病视网膜病变增生膜分级等方面比较,差异均无统计学意义( P>0.05)。两组间切割效率、切割安全性、频率波动幅度、负压波动幅度及次品检出情况比较,差异亦均无统计学意义( P>0.05)。在设备稳定性的气泡产生方面,20 k cpm S-玻切头组表现显著优于A-玻切头组,差异有统计学意义( P=0.027)。 结论:S-玻切头在多项性能指标上均不劣于A-玻切头,且在防气泡性能方面表现更优。
Abstract:
Objective:To evaluate the performance, including stability and cutting efficiency, of a domestically produced S model dual-blade, dual-port vitrectomy probe during vitrectomy surgery.Methods:A prospective, randomized controlled, non inferiority, multicenter clinical trial study. 120 patients who underwent PPV treatment at Xiamen Eye Center, Department of Ophthalmology of Peking University People’s Hospital, and Department of Ophthalmology, Peking University International Hospital in August 2025 were included in the study. According to the cutting frequency and instrument source, they are divided into 4 groups: 10 k cpm domestic S-type vitrectomy probe group, imported A-type vitrectomy probe group, and 20 k cpm S-type vitrectomy probe group and A-type vitrectomy probe group, with 30 cases in each group. The S-type vitrectomy probe adopts a double-edged dual air path design at frequencies of 10 and 20 k cpm; The A-type vitrectomy probe has a single blade design at a frequency of 10 k cpm and a double-edged design at a frequency of 20 k cpm. Compare and observe the differences in cutting efficiency, safety (incidence of iatrogenic retinal tears), and equipment stability (bubble generation, frequency and negative pressure changes, defect detection) between two groups. The comparison between groups was conducted using the chi square test.Results:Due to missing data from one patient in the 20 k cpm S-type vitrectomy probe group, 119 cases were ultimately included in the statistical analysis. Among them, there were 59 cases in the S-type probe group (30 cases at 10 k cpm and 29 cases at 20 k cpm), and 60 cases in the A-type probe group (30 cases at 10 k cpm and 20 k cpm each). There was no significant difference in age, sex composition ratio, eye type, whether to combine cataract surgery, anesthesia mode, disease classification, proliferative vitreoretinopathy and proliferative membrane grading of proliferative diabetes retinopathy between 10 k cpm, 20 k cpm S-type vitrectomy probe group and A-type vitrectomy probe group ( P>0.05). There was no statistically significant difference in cutting efficiency, cutting safety, equipment stability, frequency and negative pressure fluctuation amplitude, and defect detection between the two groups ( P>0.05). In terms of bubble generation in equipment stability, the 20 k cpm S-type vitrectomy probe group performed significantly better than the A-type vitrectomy probe group, and the difference was statistically significant ( P=0.027). Conclusion:The domestic S-type vitrectomy probe is non-inferior to the imported A-type vitrectomy probe across multiple performance indicators and shows superior anti-bubble performance.