Changes of ocular higher order aberration in keratoconus eyes wearing rigid gas-permeable contact lens
摘要
目的 探讨透气性硬性角膜接触镜(RGPCL)对屈光不正及圆锥角膜眼高阶像差的影响,以评价各期圆锥角膜戴镜后的视觉质量.方法 回顾性系列患者研究.收集原发性圆锥角膜患者56例(90只眼)及近视性屈光不正验配RGPCL患者17例(30只眼),对圆锥角膜眼进行分度,轻度者28只眼,中度者33只眼,重度者29只眼.戴镜前后在暗室环境下对近视性屈光不正及圆锥角膜戴镜前后的高阶像差、彗差、球差的变化进行观察和分析.对各组的戴镜前后各项像差的比较采用配对设计资料的t检验,对于圆锥角膜戴镜后与屈光不正裸眼的各项像差变化的比较采用独立样本t检验.结果 随着圆锥角膜程度加重,总高阶(F=72.12,P=0.00)、3阶(F=68015,P=0.00)、4阶(F=24.95,P=0.00)、总彗差(F=44.67,P=0.00)、总球差(F=28.90,P=0.01)RMS值均增加,差异有统计学意义.屈光不正眼戴镜后,总高阶像差(t=4.83)、3阶(t=4.39)、总彗差(t=3.71)降低,差异有统计学意义(P<0.05),轻度圆锥角膜眼戴镜后,总高阶(t=8.27)、3阶(t=8.14)、4阶(t=2.29)和彗差(t=4.38)降低,差异有统计学意义(P<0.05).中度圆锥角膜眼戴镜后,总高阶(t=8.03)、3阶(t=7.22)、4阶(t=4.38)、5阶(t=4.53)、彗差(t=5.26)、球差(t=2.77)均降低,差异有统计学意义(P<0.05).轻度圆锥角膜眼戴镜各阶像差可减少到正常屈光不正裸眼水平,戴镜后与屈光不正裸眼各阶像差RMS值差异(t高阶=0.63,t3阶=0.31,t4阶=1.70,t5阶=0.95,t彗差=0.06,t球差=1.99)无统计学意义(P<0.05).中度圆锥角膜眼虽然像差RMS值降低,但与正常屈光不正眼裸眼比除彗差(t彗差=2.79,P彗差=0.10)无明显差别外,其余各高阶像差RMS值均增加(t高阶=4.09,t3阶=3.14,t4阶=2.97,t5阶=2.53,t球差=2.27),差异有统计学意义(P<0.05).重度圆锥角膜眼戴镜后各高阶像差仍远高于正常屈光不正眼裸眼像差(t高价=7.50,t3阶=5.25,t4阶=5.50,t5阶=3.02,t彗差=5.90,t球差=4.60),差异有统计学意义(P<0.05).结论 配戴RGPCL可以通过降低圆锥角膜眼波阵面像差RMS值达到改善患者视觉质量的目的,但中、重度圆锥角膜虽然能获得较好的视力水平,其高阶像差仍不能达到正常屈光不正眼裸眼的水平.
Objective To compare the wavefront characteristics of normal and keratoconus eyes with and without rigid gas-permeable contact lens(RGPCL) ,and to evaluate the visual quality in keratoconus eyes corrected by RGPCL Methods Retrospective study. Higher order aberrations (HOAs) of 90 eyes in 56 keratoconus patients and 30 eyes of 17 subjects with refractive errors were quantified with a Bausch&Lomb Zywave Wavefront Analyzer. The keratoconus eyes were divided into mild (28 eyes) , moderate (33 eyes)and severe (29 eyes) groups. Zernike's polynomial was used to describe the wavefront measurements. Root mean square (RMS) values of the total HOAs, S3, S4, S5, total coma (T. Coma) and total spherical aberrations (T. Sph) were obtained in the same eye with and without contact lenses. We used paired sample t-test and independent-samples t-test to analyze the data. Results Mean RMS values for High(F=72. 12,P1 =0.00)、S3(F = 68.15,P = 0.00)、S4(F = 24.95,P=0.00)、T. Coma(F =44.67,P =0.00) 、T. Sph (F = 28. 90,P =0. 01) increased significantly from mild to sever keratoconus eyes RMS values of the total HOAs (t = 4. 83 ) , S3 (t = 4. 39 ) 、 total coma (t = 3. 71) of refractive error eyes decreased significantly after fitting with RGPCL(P<0. 05). RMS values of the total HOAs(t = 8. 27) ,S3(t = 8. 14) ,S4(t =2. 29)、total coma( t = 4. 38 ) of mild keratoconus eyes decreased significantly after fitting with RGPCL( P < 0. 05 )RMS values of the total HOAs(t =8. 03) ,S3(t=7. 22) ,s4(t=4. 38) ,S5(t=4. 53) 、total coma(t =5. 26)and total spherical (t =2. 77) of moderate keratoconus eyes decreased significantly after fitting with RGPCL ( P < 0. 05 ). Every high front-wave aberration of mild keratoconus eyes decreased to refractive error eyes'level after RGPCL fitting. Moderate (tHOAs = 0. 63, ts3 = 0. 31,t s4 = 1. 70, ts5 = 0. 95, tcoma = 0. 06,tspherical=1.99) and sever keratoconus eyes'higher order aberrations decreased significantly after RGPCL fitting (thoas=7. 50,ts3 =5. 25,1s4 =5.50,ts5 = 3.02,tcoma =5. 90,tspherical=4. 60) ,but they still degrade compared with refractive error eyes ( P < 0. 05 ). Conclusions RGPCL could reduce high aberrations and improve optical quality in keratoconus eyes. But the visual performance in moderate and severe keratoconus eyes with a RGPCLs is still poorer than that of normal eyes even if the corrected visual acuity is good.