角膜后弹力层剥除内皮移植术与深板层角膜内皮移植术远期疗效的比较
Comparison of long-term clinical outcomes between descemet's stripping endothelial keratoplasty and deep lamellar endothelial keratoplasty
摘要
目的 探讨角膜后弹力层剥除内皮移植术(DSEK)和深板层角膜内皮移植术(DLEK)后远期疗效的差异.方法 病例对照研究.收集2005年10月至2008年3月间行DLEK(26例,26只眼)和DSEK(36例,36只眼)且术前眼部条件相匹配的患者术前和术后每间隔6个月的临床资料,分析手术成功率、植片移位率、最好矫正视力(BSCVA)、植片存活率和内皮细胞密度(ECD).术后随访时间为3~5年.结果 DLEK和DSEK的手术成功率分别为88.5%和86.1%.术后12个月后的各个随访时间,两组BSCVA水平均相似.术后36个月时,DLEK和DSEK植片存活率分别为87%和75.9%,但ECD分别为1638个/mm2和1874个/mm2.术后60个月时,不论植片存活率和ECD,两组之间均相似.结论 DSEK与DLEK的手术成功率和远期的视力相似.单纯用ECD为指标评价角膜内皮移植的疗效有局限性,应综合考虑ECD和植片存活率两项因素,才能得出客观的结果.
Objective To investigate the differences of long-term clinical outcomes between two kinds of corneal endothelial keratoplasty (EK):DSEK and DLEK.Methods Retrospective,comparative,clinical case series study.Twenty-six patients (26 eyes),undergoing DLEK and thirty-six patients (36eyes),undergoing DSEK during the period of October 2005 to March 2008,were involved in this study.Before and at 6 month intervals after surgery,patients' data were collected to analyze the surgery success rate,graft dislocation rate,best corrected visual acuity (BSCVA),graft survival rate and endothelial cell density (ECD).The follow-up time was 3 to 5 years.Results The success rate of DLEK was 88.5% while DSEK was 86.1%.Average BSCVA of DLEK were similar to those of DSEK at each follow-up time after 12 months postoperatively.Graft survival rates of DLEK and DSEK were respectively 87% and 75.9%,where as ECD were respectively 1638 cells/mm2 and 1874 cells/mm2 at 36 month postoperatively,the data were similar in both ECD and graft survival rate between DLEK and DSEK at 60 months postoperatively.Conclusions The success rate and long-term visual outcomes of DLEK were similar with those of DSEK.To obtain objective results,it is better to consider both ECD and graft survival rate instead of recording ECD only for its localization in evaluating the efficacy of EK.
Author:
HUANG Ting
GAO Na
ZHANG Hong
WANG Yu-juan
WANG Yun
作者单位:
中山大学中山眼科中心,广州,510060
年,卷(期):
2012, 48(10)
分类号:
R246.82
机标分类号:
R77
R74
在线出版日期:
2012年12月27日