A comparative study of lacrimal magnetic resonance hydrography and lacrimal endoscopy examination in the diagnosis and treatment of lacrimal duct obstructive diseases
摘要
目的 评价泪道磁共振水成像(LMRH)和泪道内镜检查对泪道阻塞性疾病的诊断价值及对治疗的指导意义.方法 回顾性分析2013年1月至2014年6月于武汉同济医院行LMRH检查的59例溢泪患者的临床和影像学资料.对采集的三维T2加权图像(T2WI)进行多平面重建(MPR)和最大强度投影(MIP)后处理,观察泪囊大小、黏膜改变及鼻泪管阻塞平面位置;以泪道冲洗结果为金标准,统计分析LMRH在泪道阻塞性疾病诊断中的敏感性、特异性和准确性及两种方法之间的一致性另外,有22例患者在LMRH检查后半个月内行泪道内镜检查,其结果与LMRH影像表现进行对照分析.根据LMRH及泪道内镜结果,确定患者治疗方案.结果 根据泪道冲洗结果,59例(78只眼)患者中,泪小管阻塞2只眼(2.6%),鼻泪管狭窄8只眼(10.3%),单纯鼻泪管阻塞24只眼(30.8%),鼻泪管阻塞合并慢性泪囊炎44只眼(56.4%).另外40只眼为阴性对照组.LMRH与泪道冲洗两种方法诊断具有高度的一致性,Kappa值为0.963 (P=0.026).MRD诊断泪道阻塞性疾病的敏感性为97.4%,特异性为100%,阳性预测值为100%,阴性预测值为95.2%.根据40只对照组眼,测得泪囊最大横截面积均值为(10.9±0.4) mm2.所有患眼中有22只眼行泪道内镜检查,内镜下所见与LMRH诊断结果相符,泪道内病变显示较LMRH更加清晰、直观,而LMRH在显示泪囊大小、泪道管壁厚度、泪道较大异物及泪道周围组织病变时有其独特优势.根据LMRH及泪道内镜结果,泪小管阻塞(2只眼)、鼻泪管狭窄(8只眼)、单纯鼻泪管阻塞(20只眼)行泪道疏通和置管术,单纯鼻泪管阻塞(4只眼)行泪道内镜下注药治疗,慢性泪囊炎患者中,38只眼行经鼻泪囊鼻腔造口术,6眼行泪道置管取出和经鼻泪囊鼻腔造口术.结论 LMRH是一种无创的、可靠的泪道阻塞检查方法,能较好显示泪囊大小、泪道黏膜厚度及泪道周边软组织情况,与泪道内镜检查互为补充,可指导泪道阻塞患者的个体化治疗.
Objective To evaluate the diagnostic value and treatment guidance of lacrimal magnetic resonance hydrography (LMRH) and lacrimal endoscopy examination in lacrimal duct obstruction.Methods A retrospective analysis of clinical and imaging data of 59 patients with epiphora who had LMRH examination in Tongji Hospital during June 2013 and January 2014.Multiplanar reconstruction (MPR) and maximum intensity projection (MIP) were used to process the three dimensions T2-weighted images (T2WI).The size of lacrimal sac,lacrimal mucosal lesions and the obstructed plane of nasolacrimal duct were observed.The lacrimal irrigation results were used as gold standard.The sensitivity,specificity,accuracy of LMRH in diagnosis of lacrimal duct obstructive diseases and the consistency between the two methods were analyzed.In addition,22 cases had lacrimal endoscopy examination in less than half month after MRD.The results of lacrimal endoscopy were compared with LMRH images.The treatment method was made according to the results of LMRH and lacrimal endoscopy.Results According to the results of lacrimal irrigation,among 78 eyes of 59 patients,2 eyes were diagnosed as lacrimal canalicular obstruction (2.6%,2/78),8 eyes were diagnosed as nasolacrimal duct stenosis (10.3%,8/78),24 eyes were diagnosed as nasolacrimal duct obstruction (30.8%,24/78),44 eyes were diagnosed as nasolacrimal duct obstruction accompanied with chronic dacryocystitis (56.4%,44/78).The other 40 eyes were negative controls.LMRH had a high degree of consistency with lacrimal irrigation in diagnosis of lacrimal duct obstructive diseases.The value of Kappa was 0.963 (P=0.026).The sensitivity of MRD in diagnosis of lacrimal duct obstructive diseases was 97.4%,the specificity was 100%,the accuracy was 98.3%,the positive predictive value was 100% and the negative predictive value was 95.2%.According to 40 eyes of the control group,the mean value of the maximum cross-sectional area of the lacrimal sac was:(10.9±0.4) mm2.Twenty-two eyes underwent lacrimal endoscopy examination and the endoscopic findings were consistent with LMRH diagnosis.The lesions in the lacrimal duct displayed more clearly and intuitively than the LMRH,while LMRH had its unique advantages in showing the size of lacrimal sac,the mucosal thickness of lacrimal duct,large foreign bodies and lesions around the lacrimal duct.According to the results of LMRH and lacrimal endoscopy,2 eyes of canalicular obstruction,8 eyes of nasolacrimal duct stenosis,20 eyes of nasolacrimal duct obstruction underwent lacrimal probing and stent implantation.Four eyes of nasolacrimal duct obstruction had drug treatment under lacrimal endoscopy.Thirty-eight eyes of chronic dacryocystitis underwent endonasal dacryocystorhinostomy.The other 6 eyes of chronic dacryocystitis underwent stent removal combined with endonasal dacryocystorhinostomy.Conclusions LMRH is a noninvasive and reliable method to examine the lacrimal duct obstruction.It can better display the size of lacrimal sac,lacrimal mucosal thickness and surrounding soft tissues of lacrimal duct.It is also a good complementary method of lacrimal endoscopy and has guiding significance for individualized treatment in patients with lacrimal duct obstruction.