Application of disparity discriminating accuracy test in evaluating the stereopsis of postoperative intermittent exotropia
摘要
目的 探讨视差辨别正确率检测在间歇性外斜视术后立体视功能评估中的应用价值.方法 病例对照研究.对2011年7月至2013年6月在安徽医科大学第一附属医院眼科行斜视矫正术后眼球正位的间歇性外斜视患者进行随访,使用Titmus图谱、Randot图谱和Frisby立体板分别进行立体视功能的检测,筛选出20例立体视功能恢复正常的成年人患者作为斜视组,门诊随机选取20例健康成年人作为健康对照组,采用自行编写的视差辨别正确率检测程序进行立体视功能检测.对两组的视差辨别正确率采用双因素方差分析,对重复测量结果进行组内相关系数(ICC)分析.结果 对健康对照组的重复测量结果分析显示视差辨别正确率检测方法具有较好的重测信度(ICC=0.99,P<0.01).斜视组对具有不同视差的组合光栅的辨别正确率分别为0.56±0.09、0.67±0.14、0.77±0.15、0.82±0.14、0.85±0.11、0.85±0.14、0.87±0.10、0.84±0.16,与对照组的辨别正确率0.77±0.09、0.88±0.09、0.93±0.08、0.91±0.09、0.95±0.08、0.96±0.05、0.97±0.06、0.96±0.04相比,差异有统计学意义(F=38.06,P<0.01);两组对组合光栅的辨别能力还受到了不同大小视差的影响,小视差条件下斜视组辨别正确率(0.67±0.12)和对照组的辨别正确率(0.86±0.07)的差异更大(F=4.84,P<0.05).结论 视差辨别正确率检测可较全面地评估被试者对具有不同视差的组合光栅的辨别能力,可发现常规立体图检测正常的间歇性外斜视术后患者所存在的立体视功能异常.
Objective To discuss the application of disparity discriminating accuracy test in evaluating the stereopsis of postoperative intermittent exotropia.Methods Patients with intermittent exotropia who underwent surgery during July 2011 to June 2013 were followed up.The stereoacuity was examined by Titmus Stereotest,Randot Stereotest and Frisby Stereotest.Twenty adult cases whose stereoacuity reached normal were chosen as experimental group.Twenty healthy adults were selected as normal control group.Both groups were examined with disparity discriminating accuracy test.Discriminating accuracy of the two groups were analyzed with Two-Way ANOVA method.Test-retest reliability was analyzed with Intraclass Correlation Coefficient analysis.Results The test-retest reliability of disparity discriminating accuracy test is excellent (ICC=0.99,P<0.01).Discriminating accuracy under different disparities in experimental group were 0.56±0.09,0.67±0.14,0.77±0.15,0.82±0.14,0.85±0.11,0.85± 0.14,0.87±0.10,0.84±0.16,while those in control group were 0.77±0.09,0.88±0.09,0.93±0.08,0.91± 0.09,0.95 ±0.08,0.96±0.05,0.97 ±0.06,0.96±0.04.There were statistically significant differences between them (F=38.06,P<O.01).The discriminating ability of group grating in both groups was affected by the size of disparity.Under situation of small disparity,a large difference was found between the experimental group (0.67±0.12)and control group(0.86±0.07) (F=4.84,P<0.05).Conclusions Stereoscopic function can be evaluated comprehensively with disparity discriminating accuracy test.Use this test,a certain degree of dysfunction in stereopsis can still be found in postoperative intermittent exotropic patients who reached normal stereoacuity examined with traditional stereotests.