摘要
目的 探讨先天性上斜肌麻痹患者行上斜肌折叠术前后Bielschowsky歪头试验的变化.方法 回顾性系列病例研究.收集2014年2月至2015年2月于天津市眼科医院因先天性上斜肌麻痹行单眼上斜肌折叠的22例患者.根据患者原在位垂直斜度、眼球运动、客观旋转度数,代偿头位,采用上斜肌折叠的手术方式.采用三棱镜遮盖法定量测量Bielschowsky歪头试验,以头部向患眼侧倾斜与向健眼侧倾斜时患眼的垂直斜视度数≥5.0△为Bielschowsky歪头试验阳性.术后随访3个月至1年,平均4.6个月.采用Kolmogorov-Smirnov(K-S)、秩和检验、Spearman相关性分析等统计学方法分析数据.结果 22例患者术前均有垂直斜视、明显的代偿头位,行上斜肌折叠术后垂直斜视、代偿头位明显改善或消失,术前、术后1d、末次复诊时,双眼客观旋转度数总和分别为15.62°±7.36°、9.91°±10.09°、11.25°±9.17°,差异有统计学意义(P<0.05).术后1d、末次复诊时头部向两侧倾斜时患眼的斜视度数的差值与双眼旋转度数总和的相关性有统计学意义(P<0.05).术前、术后1d、末次复诊头部向患眼侧及健眼侧倾斜时,患眼的斜视度数的差值分别为5.00△~17.00△,平均8.68△±3.23△;1.00△~8.00△,平均为3.36△±2.01△;0.00△~14.00△,平均3.77△±3.01△.采用秩和检验,术前组与术后末次复查组组间差异有统计学意义(Z=-4.64,P<0.01).术前全部患者Bielschowsky歪头试验均为阳性,术后末次复诊17例患者Bielschowsky歪头试验转为阴性(77.3%),其余5例仍为阳性.结论 采用上斜肌折叠术治疗先天性上斜肌麻痹,术后患者Bielschowsky歪头试验转阴率较高,但仍需长期随访观察.
Objective To investigate the effect of superior oblique tucking on the Bielschowsky head tilt test.Methods A retrospective analysis of 22 patients with congenital unilateral superior oblique palsy,who underwent tucking of the superior oblique tendon in Tianjin Eye Hospital,depending on vertical deviation in the primary position,ocular motility,objective cyclotorsion and abnormal head posture.Bielschowsky head tilt test was evaluated quantitatively by the prism cover test.A positive Bielschowsky head tilt test was defined as one in which the vertical deviation when the head tilt to the side of the paresis was at least 5.0△ greater than that on tilt to the uninvolved side.The follow-up period ranged from 3 to 12 months (mean 4.6 months).Kolmogorov-Smirnov (K-S),Rank sum test and Spearman correlation analysis statistical methods were used in this study.Results All patients had vertical deviation and significant abnormal head posture before operation.After the procedure of superior oblique tucking,vertical deviation and symptom of unacceptable abnormal head posture were ameliorated or disappeared.Objective torsion was 15.62°±7.36° before the surgery,9.91°± 10.09° 1d after the surgery and 11.25°±9.17°at the last follow-up visit,respectively (P<0.05).We found that there were positive correlations between the objective cyclotorsion and the vertical deviation difference value between the paralyzed side and uninvolved side at 1 d after the surgery and last follow-up visit(P<0.05).The vertical deviation of the paresised eye when the head tilted to the side of paresis side and uninvolved side difference were 5.00△-17.00△,average 8.68△±3.23△,1.00 △-8.00 △,average 3.36 △ ± 2.01 △ and 0.00 △-14.00 △,average 3.77 △ ± 3.01 △,preoperatively,1d after the surgery and at the last follow-up visit respectively.Using Rank sum test,the pre-and postoperative difference was statistically significant (Z=-4.64,P<0.01).A positive Bielschowsky head tilt test was found in all cases preoperatively.The results of Bielschowsky tilt test was still positive in 5 cases and negative in 17 cases (77.3%).Conclusions In most cases with unilateral superior oblique paresis,the results of Bielschowsky tilt test became negative after superior oblique tucking.The long-standing results is worthy of observation.