超声检测与传统方法用于小儿骶管阻滞的比较
A comparison of ultrasonography versus traditional approach for caudal block in children
摘要
目的 比较采用超声定位与传统定位对小儿骶管阻滞的监测效果.方法 经医院伦理委员会审核通过及患儿家长知情同意后,2010年6月至2011年5月,选择入住天津市儿童医院拟行尿道或会阴部手术、美国麻醉医师协会(ASA)Ⅰ~Ⅱ级小儿102例,按数字表随机法分为超声组(n=52)和对照组(n=50),采用超声法和体表标志法,确定骶管穿刺点后进行穿刺,用超声法和Swoosh法同时监测注药时骶腔管的反应,观察并记录相关数据.结果 超声组与对照组患儿,穿刺次数分别是(1.10±0.30)次和(1.56±0.63)次,操作时间分别为(1.40±0.39) min和(3.23±1.23)min,一针穿刺成功率分别为90.4%和66%,总穿刺成功率分别为100%和92%.对骶管麻醉针位置正确判断的阳性率超声法和Swoosh法分别为97.96%和62.24%.超声法各项指标均优于传统法(P<0.01).结论 应用超声定位和监测行小儿骶管阻滞优于传统方法,具有较高的临床使用价值.
Objective To apply ultrasoni(c) technology in positioning and monitoring for pediatric caudal blocks and comparc it with traditional landmark approach and Swoosh test.Methods After obtaining the approval of hospital ethics committee and written parental informed consent,a total of 102 American Society of Anesthesiologists (ASA) Ⅰ- Ⅱ pediatric patients aged from 1 month to 8 years and scheduled for urologic or perineal surgery were recruited.Patients were randomly divided into 2 groups:ultrasound group (n =52 ) and control group (n =50 ).The sites of sacral cornu and sacral hiatus were determined by ultrasonic imaging or classic method of anatomical surface landmarks.Patients of two groups were punctured according to the scheduled site.Local anesthetic was injected slowly into caudal space after a successful caudal puncture and the positive reaction in caudal space was monitored simultaneously by ultrasound and classic swoosh test.The observational results and relevant date were recorded.Results In ultrasound and control groups,the number of puncture attempts was 1.10 ± 0.30 vs 1.56 ± 0.63,the duration of puncture ( 1.40 ± 0.39 ) vs ( 3.23 ± 1.23 ) min,the success rate at the first puncture attempt 90.4% vs 66% and the total puncture success ratc 100% vs 92% respectively.After the injection of local anesthetic,the positive reaction rate of ultrasonography and swoosh test was 97.96% vs 62.24% respectively.All of above results in ultrasound group were superior to those in control group or with classic test.And the difference had statistical significance (P < 0.01 ).Conclusion Ultrasonic positioning and monitoring for pediatric caudal block is both scientific and reasonable.The positioning detected by ultrasonic imaging is accurate and the monitoring results of ultrasound are reliable.It is obviously superior to traditional method and has clinical application values for caudal block in children.
Author:
LIU Jin-zhu
WU Xue-qing
LI Rong
ZHANG Yan-jun
作者单位:
300074,天津市儿童医院麻醉科
年,卷(期):
2012, 92(13)
分类号:
R614
机标分类号:
H31
TG4
在线出版日期:
2012年7月17日