Objective To evaluate the rationality of different radical operative modalities for proximal gastric cancer. Methods A total of 366 cases of proximal gastric cancer undergoing radical dissection were screened from data base. According to the operative modalities,they were divided into proximal gastrectomy group (PG) ( n =77) and total gastrectomy group (TG) ( n =289 ).Through the comparisons of clinical pathologic features,surgical profiles,postoperative complications,postoperative quality-of-life and prognosis in two groups,the rationality of different operative modalities was evaluated.Results No significant differences existed in age,gender or carcinombryonic antigen (CEA) value between two groups ( all P > 0.05 ). The rates of tumor diameter ≥ 5 cm,organic infiltration,lymph nodes metastasis,distal organs metastasis,infiltrative type,poorly differentiated tumor in PG and TG groups were 15.6%(12/77) vs 49.8% (144/289),16.9% (13/77) vs 37.7% (109/289),67.5% (52/77) vs 79.9% (231/289),3.9% (3/77) vs 11.4% (33/289),45.5% (35/77) vs 68.9% ( 199/289),32.5%(25/77) vs 57.8% ( 167/289 ) respectively ( all P < 0.05 ).Operative duration,volume of blood transfusion,number of dissected lymph nodes and positive lymph nodes,rate of combined organic resection and complications in groups of PG and TG were (256 ± 83 ) vs (298 ± 86) main,0 vs 400 ml,15 ± 12 vs 26 ±15,0 vs 3,15.6% (12/77) vs 43.2% (125/289),14.3% (11/77) vs 7.6% (22/289) respectively (all P < 0.05 ). In two groups,the evaluating indices of posteroperative quality-of-life showed no significant differences ( P > 0.05 ).In two groups,the median survival time of the cases with tumor diameter < 5 cm,no-organic infiltration,no-peri-tumor lymph nodes metastasis,no-distal organic metastasis had no significant difference ( all P > 0.05). However,in groups of PG and TG,the median survival time of the cases with tumor diameter ≥5 cm,organic infiltration,peri-tumor lymph nodes metastasis and distal organic metastasis was 15.0 months vs 29.0 months,15.0 months vs 30.0 months,34.0 months vs 45.0 months,4.0 months vs 18.0 months respectively( all P < 0.05).Conclusion As compared with radical proximal gastrectomy,radical total gastrectomy improves significantly the prognosis of patients of proximal gastric cancer with organic infiltration,peri-tumor lymph nodes metastasis,distal organic metastasis and tumor diameter≥5 cm.