摘要
目的 应用荟萃分析系统评价肺血栓栓塞症(PTE)发生再栓塞的相关危险因素.方法 系统检索中国期刊全文数据库、中国生物医学数据库、PubMed数据库、西文生物医学数据库1995年1月至2011年5月公开发表的关于PTE再栓塞相关危险因素的研究论文,并查阅各个研究中引用的参考文献来补充.观察性研究(队列研究和病例对照研究)参照文献关于观察性研究方法学质量评估的建议进行评价;随机对照研究利用Jadad量表进行评价.应用Cochrane协作网提供的RevMan 5.1软件,进行一致性检验,使用固定效应模型及随机效应模型进行合并,计算相对危险度(RR)及其95% CI.结果 纳入42篇文献,共计36909例PTE伴或不伴深静脉血栓患者.再栓塞的相关危险因素为D-二聚体水平升高[1.77( 1.34 ~2.36),P=0.000]、特发性PTE[1.82( 1.61~2.05),P=0.000]、右室功能不全(RVD)[持续性RVD比RVD恢复:8.71(2.38~31.91),P=0.001;持续性RVD比未发生RVD:2.45( 1.26 ~4.76),P=0.008]、抗凝疗程不足[1.73(1.32~2.28),P=0.000]、凝血酶生成潜力升高[1.89( 1.39~ 2.56),P=0.000]、凝血因子Ⅷ升高[1.96(1.40 ~2.74),P=0.000]、抗磷脂抗体阳性[5.64(4.09 ~7.77),P=0.000]、抗凝血酶缺陷[2.45(1.26 ~4.76),P=0.008]、男性[1.47 (1.06~2.03),P=0.020].多种相关危险因素并存时再栓塞风险大于单一因素.结论 D-二聚体水平升高、特发性PTE等多种因素均为再栓塞发生的危险因素,再栓塞患者常有多种危险因素并存.
Objective To evaluate the risk factors of recurrent pulmonary thromboembolism (PTE) through Meta-analysis.Methods Chinese Journal Full-text Database, Chinese Biomedical Database,PubMed and Foreign Medical Journal Full-Text Service were searched for the paper relating to the risk factors of recurrent PTE from January 1995 to May 2011. And the references of these studies were also examined.Observational studies (cohort & case control) were assessed according to the method of quality assessment suggested within the references. Randomized control trials (RCTs) were assessed by the Jadad scale.Software RevMan 5.1 was used to examin the heterogeneity of trials.The fixed or random effect model was pooled to calculate the risk ratio (RR).And the results were expressed by RR (95% CI).Results Fortytwo trials including 36 909 cases of PTE and/or deep vein thrombosis were analyzed. And the following factors were relative to recurrence:elevated D-dimer ( 1.77 ( 1.34 - 2.36 ),P =0.000 ),idiopathic PTE (1.82(1.61 -2.05),P =0.000),right ventricular dysfunction (RVD) (persistent RVD vs RVD regression (8.71 (2.38 - 31.91 ),P =0.001 ) ; persistent RVD vs non-RVD (2.45 ( 1.26 - 4.76),P =0.008),short anticoagulation duration ( 1.73 ( 1.32 - 2.28),P =0.000),increased endogenous thrombin generation capacity ( 1.89 ( 1.39 - 2.56 ),P =0.000 ),elevated factor Ⅷ ( 1.96 ( 1.40 - 2.74 ),P =0.000),positive antiphospholipid antibodies (5.64 (4.09 - 7.77 ),P =0.000),anti-thrombin defect (2.45(1.26-4.76),P=0.008) and males (1.47(1.06-2.03),P=0.020),etc.When multiple factors co-existed,the risk of recurrence became more obvious.Conclusions Elevated D-dimer,idiopathic PTE and many other factors may influence the recurrence of pulmonary embolism. And most recurrent patients have two or more factors.