Impact of lacrimal obstruction type on the efficacy of probing for congenital nasolacrimal duct obstruction
摘要
目的 分析患儿先天性泪道阻塞临床分型对泪道探通疗效的影响.方法 回顾性系列研究.对2009年11月至2011年11月门诊就诊的先天性泪道阻塞患儿741例872眼采用表面麻醉下泪道探通术,对于首次泪道探通失败的患儿于术后4周行再次泪道探通术.根据泪道阻塞情况分为单纯型和复杂型,并根据首次泪道探通的年龄分组为幼龄组和大龄组.观察不同临床分型、不同组别患儿的首次及再次泪道探通治愈率.采用x2检验进行统计学分析.结果 幼龄组泪道探通总治愈率(90.0%)明显高于大龄组(70.4%,x2=38.527,P<0.01);而单纯型中幼龄组总治愈率(92.4%)与大龄组(91.7%)比较,差异无统计学意义(x2=0.054,P=0.815);复杂型中幼龄组总治愈率(48.8%)与大龄组(35.3%)比较,差异亦无统计学意义(x2=1.705,P=0.192);幼龄组中单纯型的构成比(94.4%)明显高于大龄组(62.2%,x2=125.471,P<0.01).单纯型中幼龄组再通治愈率(61.9%)与大龄组(68.2%)比较,差异无统计学意义(x2=0.324,P=0.569);复杂型中幼龄组再通治愈率(19.2%)与大龄组(5.7%)比较,差异亦无统计学意义(Fisher's Exact Test,P=0.125);无论幼龄或大龄组,单纯型再通治愈率均明显高于复杂型(x2幼龄组=16.100,P<0.01;x2大龄组=25.186,P<0.01).结论 复杂型先天性泪道阻塞在大龄患儿中的构成比增高是导致大龄患儿泪道探通治愈率降低的原因.泪道探通对大龄患儿,尤其大龄单纯型患儿仍具有较满意的疗效,故可作为1岁以上患儿的首选治疗.对首次泪道探通失败的患儿,单纯型者建议术后4周行再次探通,复杂型者建议行硅胶管植入或气囊导管扩张等其他手术方法.
Objective To explore the impact of lacrimal obstruction type on the efficacy of lacrimal probing in the treatment of congenital nasolacrimal duct obstruction.Methods We conducted a retrospective study in which 872 eyes of 741 children with congenital nasolacrinal duct obstruction underwent nasolacrimal duct probing under superficial anesthesia.Two types of obstructions were encountered during probing,i.e.simple and complex.They were divided into early (4-12 months) and late ( 1-4 years) groups based upon the age at the time of initial probing.Those refractory to the first probing underwent a second probing 4 weeks later.The main observation criterion was the success rate of probing.Results The success rate was 90.0%in early group versus 70.4% in late group (x2 =38.527,P <0.01 ).No significant difference existed in the cure rate of simple or complex obstruction between two groups (x2 simple =0.054,P =0.815,x2 complex =1.705,P =0.192).The proportion of simple obstruction was 94.4% in early group versus 62.2% in late group.Difference was statistically significant (x2 =125.471,P < 0.01 ).The success rate of a second probing of simple obstruction was 61.9% in early group versus 68.2% in late group (x2 =0.324,P =0.569 ).The success rate of a second probing of complex obstruction was 19.2% in early group versus 5.7%in late group (Fisher's exact test,P =0.125).For either group,the success rate of a second probing of simple obstruction was higher than that of complex obstruction (x2 early group =16.100,P < 0.01 ; x2 late group =25.186,P < 0.01 ).Conclusion Unsuccessful probing may result from the selection of complex obstructions.Probing should remain the first-line treatment in children above 1 year of age.The success rate with a second probing was significantly lower in patients of complex obstruction.Other surgical interventions,such as silicone tube intubation or balloon dacryocystoplasty,should be recommended instead of repeated probing for the patients of complex obstruction if an initial probing fails.