Different treatments on the prognosis of poor-grade aneurysmal subarachnoid hemorrhage patients
摘要
目的 观察对比手术夹闭、介入治疗和保守治疗对高分级动脉瘤患者的治疗效果.方法 回顾性分析2004年6月至2011年12月山东大学第二医院神经外科收治的世界神经外科医师联盟(WFNS)分级Ⅳ、Ⅴ级患者119例.其中WFNS Ⅳ级73例,Ⅴ级46例.男51例,女68例,年龄32 ~ 77岁,平均55.2岁.手术夹闭57例,介入栓塞40例,保守治疗22例.术后3个月行格拉斯哥预后评分( GOS).结果 手术夹闭组预后好(5~4分)22例(38.6%);预后差(3~2分)30例(52.6%);死亡(1分)5例(8.8%).介入栓塞组预后好26例(65.0%);预后差1例(2.5%);死亡13例(32.5%).保守治疗组预后好0例;预后差3例(13.6%);死亡19例(86.4%).介入栓塞预后好的结果高于手术夹闭和保守治疗(P<0.05),病死率高于手术夹闭(P<0.05),保守组的病死率明显高于前两组(P<0.05).结论 对于WFNS Ⅳ级患者,手术夹闭和介入栓塞均可选择;在WFNS Ⅴ 级患者中,介入栓塞可作为首选;当WFNSⅣ级和Ⅴ级患者合并脑内较大血肿(血肿量>30 ml)时,应首选手术夹闭.
Objective To compare the outcomes of surgical clipping,interventional treatment and conservative treatment of poor-grade aneurysm patients.Methods A total of 119 patients of WFNS( World Federation of Neurosurgical Societies ) grades Ⅳ ( n =73 ) and Ⅴ ( n =46 ) from June 2004 from to December 2011 were analyzed.There were 51 males and 68 female with a mean age of 55.2 years (range:32-77).The approaches included surgical clipping ( n =57 ),interventional embolization ( n =40) and conservative treatment (n =22).Their outcome were assessed with a 3-month follow-up according to the Glasgow outcome score (GOS).Results In surgical clipping group,the prognoses were excellent (5-4points,n =22),poor prognosis (3-2 points,n =30) and death ( 1 point,n =5) ; excellent ( n =26),poor ( n =1 ) and death ( n =13 ) in interventional embolization group ; excellent ( n =0 ),poor ( n =3 ) and death (n =19) in conservative treatment.The excellent outcome of interventional embolism was better than those of surgical clipping and conservative treatment ( P < 0.05 ),but it had higher mortality than surgical clipping (P < 0.05).In conservative treatment group,mortality was significantly higher than the first two groups ( P < 0.05).Conclusion For patients of grade Ⅳ,surgical clipping and interventional embolization may be selected ; for those of grade Ⅴ,interventional embolization can be used as a first choice; for those of grade Ⅳ/Ⅴ with large intracerebral hematoma (hematoma volume > 30 ml), surgical clipping is preferred.