Comparison of radiofrequency catheter ablation for paroxysmal supraventricular tachycardia guided by three dimensional navigation with X-ray
摘要
目的 通过比较三维导航和X线透视下的阵发性室上性心动过速(PSVT)导管射频消融术(RFCA)治疗的差异,研究三维导航下PSVT的RFCA的可行性.方法 收集自2013年1月至2014年12月就诊于浙江省人民医院心内科的176例PSVT患者临床数据,根据不同的术式分成A组(95例)和B组(81例),A组在三维电场导航系统(NavX)引导下,采用空间定位法行RFCA,手术过程中导管无法到位时可在X透视下操作;B组完全在X线透视下完成RFCA,统计分析两组的成功率、复发率、手术时间、X线曝光量.结果 176例PSVT患者,手术即刻成功率100%,无并发症发生,随访中A组复发2例,B组复发1例;手术时间A组(97±20) min,B组(91±26) min;A组X线透视时间中位数3.0 min,曝光量为18.5 μGym2,B组透视时间34.5 min,曝光量167.3 uGym2.A组的透视时间、透视量明显低于B组(P<0.05),手术时间、手术成功率差异无统计学意义(P>0.05).结论 在经验丰富的电生理中心三维电场导航下PSVT的RFCA是安全、有可行的,多数患者手术可在非透视下或极少射线量下完成.
Objective To compare the therapeutic efficiency and safety of radiofrequency catheter ablation (RFCA) for paroxysmal ventricular tachycardia (PSVT) guided by three-dimensional navigation with X-ray.Methods One hundred and seventy-six patients with PSVT hospitalized in Department of Cardiology,Zhejiang Provincial People's Hospital between January 2013 and December 2014 were enrolled in this study.RFCA was performed on 95 patients (Group A) guided by the three dimensional electric-field navigation system (NavX) and the procedures were done with the spatial localization method,unless X-ray was needed in some cases.Eighty-one patients (Group B) underwent RFCA guided by X-ray only.The success rate,complications,recurrence rate,operation time,and X-ray exposure were compared between the two groups.Results The immediate success rate of operation was 100% in the 176 PSVT patients without complications.There were recurrences in 2 cases of Group A,while in 1 case of Group B.The average operation time in Group A was (97 ±20) min,while (91 ±26) min in Group B.The median X-ray fluoroscopy time was 3.0 min and radiation dose was 18.5 μGym2 in Group A,which were significantly reduced compared with those in Group B (34.5 min,167.3 μ Gym2) (P < 0.05).There was no significant difference in immediate procedure success rate,complications,recurrence,and operative time between this two groups (P > O.05).Conclusions The RFCA for PSVT guided by three-dimensional navigation is safe and feasible in the experienced electrophysiological center.Most patients suffer less or no X-ray radiation.