军事知识服务平台
基于DEA和Malmquist指数模型的新疆卫生资源配置效率分析
Analysis of the efficiency of health resource allocation in Xinjiang Uygur Autonomous Region based on the DEA and Malmquist index models
摘要 目的:评估新疆卫生资源配置效率演变特征,为区域卫生资源优化配置提供依据。方法:基于《新疆统计年鉴》,选取2016—2022年新疆14个地州市(参照各地机动车牌编码首字母编码为A~R)的面板数据,将医疗机构数、床位数和卫生技术人员数作为投入指标;对门诊次均费用、人均住院费用和日均住院费用进行倒数处理,作为产出指标。综合运用数据包络分析中的BCC和CCR模型分析卫生资源配置静态效率,Malmquist指数分析动态效率。结果:静态效率分析显示,新疆卫生资源配置综合技术效率(0.585)整体偏低且逐年提升缓慢。分区域看,北疆综合技术效率(0.654)优于南疆(0.474),其中北疆纯技术效率(0.710)和规模效率(0.904)均高于南疆(0.678和0.747),规模效率差距(0.157)是区域差异的主要因素。从规模报酬类型分布看,北疆有7个地州市为规模报酬递减型,2个处于不变状态;南疆2个地州市为规模报酬递增型,1个为不变型,2个为递减型。动态效率分析显示,新疆整体全要素生产率呈波动上升趋势,Malmquist指数均值为1.049,技术效率变化贡献(82.0%)大于技术进步(18.0%)。分区域看,北疆Malmquist指数均值为1.050,略高于南疆的1.045;就效率改善而言,北疆主要依赖技术效率变化(1.042),南疆主要依赖技术进步(1.011);从各地州市来看,8个地州市(Malmquist指数=1.015~1.112)实现效率改善,6个地州市(Malmquist指数=0.965~0.998)持续衰退。结论:新疆卫生资源配置效率长期偏低,呈缓慢升高趋势;全要素生产率增长主要依赖技术效率改善,技术进步驱动不足。南北疆存在效率差距,北疆多数地区处于规模报酬递减,面临资源冗余压力,应盘活存量,推进精细化管理;南疆各地规模报酬类型呈现多样性,应分类施策,针对规模报酬递增地区持续加大资源投入、扩大服务规模,针对规模报酬递减地区重点提升管理效能、盘活存量资源,精准匹配投入与管理策略。
Abstract:
Objective:To assess the evolution characteristics of health resource allocation efficiency in Xinjiang Uygur Autonomous Region from 2016 to 2022, so as to provide evidence for optimizing regional health resource allocation.Methods:Based on the Xinjiang Statistical Yearbook, panel data from 14 prefecture-level divisions (based on the first letter of mottor vehide license plate codes in various prefecture-level divisions, the codes were A-R) in Xinjiang Uygur Autonomous Region from 2016 to 2022 were selected. The number of medical institutions, beds, and health technicians were used as input indicators; outpatient cost per visit, inpatient cost per capita, and average daily inpatient cost were processed by inverse transformation as output indicators. The BCC and CCR models of data envelopment analysis were used to analyze the static efficiency of health resource allocation, and the Malmquist index was employed for dynamic efficiency assessment. Results:Static efficiency analysis showed that the average comprehensive efficiency of health resource allocation in Xinjiang was low (0.585), but increased gradually year by year. Regionally, the mean comprehensive efficiency in northern Xinjiang was 0.654, significantly higher than that in southern Xinjiang (0.474). Specifically, Northern Xinjiang′s pure technical efficiency (0.710) and scale efficiency (0.904) were both higher than those of Southern Xinjiang (0.678 and 0.747), with the gap in scale efficiency (0.157) being the primary factor driving the regional disparity. In terms of the distribution of types of returns to scale, 7 prefectures and cities in Northern Xinjiang exhibited diminishing returns, while 2 remained constant. In Southern Xinjiang, 2 prefectures and cities exhibited increasing returns to scale, 1 remained constant, and 2 exhibited diminishing returns. Dynamic analysis revealed that total factor productivity of Xinjiang exhibited a fluctuating upward trend, with an average Malmquist index of 1.049, in which technical efficiency change contributed 82.0% and technological progress contributed 18.0%. Regionally, the mean Malmquist index in northern Xinjiang was 1.050, slightly higher than that in southern Xinjiang (1.045); efficiency improvement in northern Xinjiang relied mainly on technical efficiency change (1.042), while Southern Xinjiang relied relatively more on technological progress (1.011). In terms of the various prefectures and cities, 8 of them achieved efficiency improvement with Malmquist indexs ranging from 1.015 to 1.112, while 6 experienced continuous decline with Malmquist indexs ranging from 0.965 to 0.998.Conclusions:The efficiency of health resource allocation in Xinjiang had remained persistently low but with a slow increasing trend. The growth of the total factor productivity relied mainly on technical efficiency improvement, with insufficient impetus from technological progress. An efficiency gap existed between northern and southern Xinjiang. Most regions in northern Xinjiang were in the stage of decreasing returns to scale and face resource redundancy pressures; thus, they should revitalize existing resources and promote refined management. Southern Xinjiang exhibited diversity in returns to scale across regions and should adopt classified policies: regions with increasing returns to scale should continue to increase resource input and expand service scale, while regions with decreasing returns to scale should focus on improving management effectiveness, revitalizing existing resources, and precisely matching investment with management strategies.