军事知识服务平台
构建数字师徒共同体:学徒制智能化转型的路向
Building a Digital Master-Apprentice Community:Pathways for the Intelligent Transformation of Apprenticeship—A Qualitative Study Based on Reflexive Thematic Analysis
摘要 人工智能的深度介入正推动中国特色学徒制经历一场深刻的范式革命.本文以15名学徒、8名企业师傅、5名院校教师为访谈对象,采用反思性主题分析法开展质性研究.研究发现,人工智能催生了学徒培养中的"精准可视化悖论",各主体在快速获得技能提升掌控感的同时,也面临数据监控带来的心理焦虑;传统二元师徒关系迭代为学徒—师傅—人工智能的"人机三重奏"新格局,逐步形成数字师徒共同体,权威逻辑由经验独占转向算法协商;人工智能在促进技能标准化训练加速的同时,也造成各主体间具身认知的疏离与隔阂.研究表明,技术赋能学徒制改革需兼顾主体利益、情感联结与试错空间,避免数据对技能习得的"殖民",从而破解"校热企冷"、培养内容滞后、评价方式单一等现实困境.
Abstract:
The in-depth intervention of artificial intelligence technology is driving a profound paradigmatic revolution in Chinese-style apprenticeship.Taking 15 apprentices,8 enterprise masters and 5 college teachers as interviewees,this study conducts qualitative research using Braun-Clarke reflexive thematic analysis.The findings indicate that AI technology gives rise to the paradox of precise visualization in apprentice training:while stakeholders gain a sense of mastery from rapid skill improvement,they also suffer psychological anxiety induced by data-driven monitoring.The traditional dual master-apprentice relationship has evolved into a new pattern of human-machine trio comprising apprentices-masters-AI,which gradually fosters a digital master-apprentice community.The logic of authority has shifted from exclusive reliance on experience to algorithmic negotiation.While AI accelerates standardized skill training,it also engenders alienation and estrangement of embodied cognition among stakeholders.This study suggests that technology-empowered reform of the apprenticeship system should balance stakeholder interests,emotional bonds and room for trial-and-error.It is necessary to avoid the colonization of skill acquisition by data,so as to address practical dilemmas including the dilemma of enthusiastic schools yet indifferent enterprises,outdated training content,and single-method evaluation approaches.
刊 名 职教论坛 ISTICPKU
年,卷(期): 2026, 42(9)
分类号: G710
机标分类号: F49 F832.33 F272
在线出版日期: 2026年11月4日
基金项目: ZJYB138:教育部职业院校中国特色学徒制教委一般课题20230205146:河北省社会科学发展研究课题,