军事知识服务平台
机械领域开放式与封闭式权利要求的判定方法研究
Research on Determination Methods of Open-Ended and Closed-Ended Claims in the Mechanical Field:An Empirical Analysis Based on Typical Judicial Cases
摘要 判断机械领域权利要求或技术特征是开放式还是封闭式,实务中容易引发争议.文章通过分析相关典型案例,提炼出司法实践的判定方法:以本领域技术人员的视角,综合考量权利要求的表达方式、发明目的以及专利权人的真实意思,进行整体认定.文章进一步指出,当机械领域权利要求或技术特征整体为开放式,同时又限定其组成部件的具体数量时,对该具体数量作出的封闭式或开放式的解释,应得到说明书的支持.
Abstract:
In patent practice,determining whether a claim or technical feature in the mechanical field should be construed as open-ended or closed-ended often gives rise to controversy.Through the analysis of relevant typical cases,this article outlines the judicial approach to such determination:from the perspective of a person skilled in the art,by comprehensively considering the wording of the claim,the purpose of the invention,and the true intention of the patentee,a holistic assessment is made.Furthermore,it clarifies that when a claim or technical feature in the mechanical field is drafted in an open-ended manner while simultaneously specifying a specific number of its constituent components,the interpretation of that specific number,either as closed-ended or open-ended must be supported by the specification.
刊 名 专利代理
年,卷(期): 2026, (3)
分类号: D923.42
机标分类号: R1 D923.42 G306
在线出版日期: 2026年10月10日