摘要
标准必要专利临时许可是英国法院在全球标准必要专利治理规则方面的一次制度路径探索.正当性基础是临时许可制度的构建前提,该制度正当性可从规范正当性、效率正当性、法理正当性三重维度加以证成.规范正当性植根于FRAND原则,以诚信原则为逻辑主线、以促成FRAND许可为制度目标的临时许可制度,本质上为FRAND原则内涵的制度化表达.效率正当性源于博弈论下的效率调节需要,通过调控成本收益结构,临时许可制度为实现个人理性与整体理性的激励相容提供制度路径,从而趋近帕累托最优状态.法理正当性在于,法院授予临时许可声明的司法介入行为,既尊重当事人意思自治的边界,亦能消解因程序延迟所致的正义损耗.
The interim licensing of standard essential patent(SEP)represents an exploration of institutional pathways by the UK courts in the global governance of SEPs.The legitimate basis is the foundational premise for constructing the interim license system,which can be justified from three dimensions:normative legitimacy,efficiency legitimacy,and jurisprudential legitimacy.Normative legitimacy is rooted in the FRAND principle.The interim license system,which takes the principle of good faith as its logical thread and the facilitation of FRAND licensing as its institutional goal,is essentially an institutionalized expression of the connotation of the FRAND principle.Efficiency legitimacy stems from the need for efficiency regulation under game theory.By adjusting the cost-benefit structure,the interim license system provides an institutional pathway for achieving incentive compatibility between individual rationality and collective rationality,thereby approaching the Pareto optimal state.Jurisprudential legitimacy relies on that the judicial intervention act of a court issuing an interim license declaration does not overstep the boundaries of party autonomy,while also being capable of resolving the loss of justice caused by procedural delay.