摘要
知识产权的私权属性与公共利益属性是相伴而生的,知识产权领域同样存在公益保护主体缺位情形,且"公共利益"可被场景化梳理,这些因素共同构成了知识产权检察公益诉讼的现实动因.借助法解释学方法,可对知识产权具体制度中承载"公共利益"意义的规范进行发现.知识产权检察公益诉讼的适用场景,可从违反公共利益之知识产权授权(登记)行为、违反诚实信用原则之知识产权滥用行为和涉及公共利益的知识产权侵权(假冒)行为等角度梳理.针对不同的知识产权检察公益诉讼场景,应以现有法律规范为基础,分类采取检察建议、提起行政公益诉讼、提起民事公益诉讼、支持起诉等监督路径.
The private right nature and public interest characteristic of intellectual property rights(IPRs)are inherently intertwined.The field of intellectual property(IP)also faces a lack of dedicated entities responsible for public interest protection.The concept of"public interest"can be sorted out within scenarios.These factors collectively constitute the realistic motivation of procuratorial public interest litigation on IP.Norms within specific IP systems that embody the meaning of"public interest"can be identified by the method of legal hermeneutics.The applicable scenarios of IP procuratorial public interest litigation can be sorted out from perspectives such as IP authorization(registration)practices that violate public interests,IP abuse behaviors contravening the principle of good faith,and IP infringement(counterfeiting)acts involving public interests.For different types of IP procuratorial public interest litigation scenarios,classified supervision paths should be adopted based on existing legal norms,including procuratorial suggestions,initiation of administrative public interest litigation,filing civil public interest litigation,or supporting litigation efforts.