摘要
生成式人工智能企业依监管要求留存的内容安全合规记录,本是证明行政合规的凭证,但在特定情形中,该类记录可被权利人援用支撑版权侵权主张,成为法院判断企业版权侵权风险认知水平、控制能力、防范措施完备性与主观过错的事实依据.在美国跨境版权诉讼场景下,高额诉讼成本与国际舆论压力,会显著加大我国出海企业的举证压力与经营风险.内容安全合规事实能否纳入民事侵权责任评价,需要结合规范来源、侵权责任构成要件、证明范围综合分析.我国应厘清内容安全合规义务事实与著作权注意义务事实的边界,围绕行政合规事实介入民事侵权责任判断的适用条件、技术能力转化为注意义务的限度、训练端—输出端—通知处置端的分层治理规则,以及出海企业合规指引与版权侵权风险预警机制,构建体系化的跨境版权争议应对规则.
Content security compliance records retained by generative artificial intelligence companies in response to regulatory requirements are generally used to demonstrate compliance with administrative obligations.Such records,however,may also be invoked by right holders to support copyright infringement claims and,under certain circumstances,may serve as factual evidence in a court's assessments of copyright-infringement risk awareness,ability to control,the adequacy of preventive measures,or subject fault.In cross-border copyright litigation in the United States,high litigation costs and sustained international scrutiny may intensify the evidentiary burdens and operational risks on Chinese enterprises going global.Whether facts of content security compliance may be incorporated into assessment of civil liability should be assessed in light of their normative sources,constituent elements of liability,and the scope of proof.China should clarify the distinguish between facts of content security compliance obligations and facts of duty of care for copyright infringement.It should further develop rules governing the conditions under which administrative compliance facts may enter into civil liability determination,the limits on translating technical capabilities into duties of care,the layered rules for model training,content output,and notification and handling,as well as compliance guidance and risk-warning mechanisms for enterprises going global,thereby establishing a more systematic framework for addressing cross-border copyright disputes.