军事知识服务平台
数智时代版权侵权平台责任判定的权责匹配逻辑
摘要 版权法是维系多方利益平衡的法律框架,"先授权再使用"规则一直支撑着内容产业的健康发展.信息技术的快速更迭改变了传统的内容产业生态链,互联网发展初期对仅提供技术服务、不介入版权内容经营的平台中立性之假定,已不适用于数智时代越来越多以技术控制内容生产和传播、以流量分成作为营收的多功能综合平台.基于"避风港"规则适用在我国遭遇多重困境和平台"注意义务"标准设定无法形成共识的现实,结合数智技术掌控者已深度介入和实质性控制内容产业运行的实际,应更新平台版权侵权责任判定的理念,依权责匹配逻辑按"技术—市场"控制力高低,分层判定不同类型平台的侵权责任,尤其是基于用户协议直接控制用户内容传播并以此获利的平台之替代责任.
Abstract:
Copyright law constitutes a legal framework for balancing the interests of various parties.The rule of prior authorization before use has consistently supported the sustainable and healthy develop-ment of the content industry.The rapid iteration of information technologies has reshaped the ecological chain of the traditional content industry.In the early stages of internet development,platforms were as-sumed to be neutral because they merely provided technical services without participating in the exploita-tion of copyright content.Such an assumption is incapable of capturing the realities of contemporary mul-tifunctional platforms that increasingly not only exercise technological control over the production,dis-semination,and distribution of content but also derive substantial economic benefits through flow-based monetization and revenue-sharing mechanisms in this digital-intelligence era.Based on the fact that the application of the"safe harbor"rule has encountered multiple difficulties and that no consensus has yet e-merged regarding the appropriate standard of"duty of care"owed by online platforms,combined with the reality that digital platform operators have become deeply embedded in and exert substantial control over the operation of content markets,the conceptual framework of determining platform liability should be renewed.Adhere to the principle of matching right and liability the allocation of copyright infringement liability should be differentiated according to the degree of"technology-market"control exercised by a platform.When the platforms directly control the dissemination of user-generated contents through con-tractual User Agreements,and derive benefits therefrom,such platforms should be subject to vicarious liability.
刊 名 中外法学 ISTICPKU
年,卷(期): 2026, 38(4)
机标分类号: D922.294 G206 TP393
在线出版日期: 2026年9月11日