军事知识服务平台
无罪推定原则的实质内涵及其合宪性调控
摘要 无罪推定原则的形式内涵主要关注证明机制,体现了形式法治和民主人权的基本特征.然而,形式内涵无法跟进程序法理论和制度的发展趋势,在实体法领域放弃了对立法权的间接调控,更无法因应以安全和预防为导向的刑事立法和政策对该原则的冲击和侵蚀.无罪推定原则实质内涵之提出凸显了该原则的宪法位阶和基本权属性,符合实质法治和刑事一体化要求.实质内涵填补了形式内涵的盲区,将无罪推定的规范效力延伸至量刑、涉案财物处置等领域,协助罪刑法定原则在划定犯罪圈、分配证明责任、设置推定和抗辩、界定主观要素等方面落实内容适正和实质正义的双重要求.无罪推定原则之限制应通过比例原则及其教义体系的合宪性审查,尤其是在狭义比例原则的判断层面维系争点重要性和被告人防御权之间的损益均衡,判断和论证系争条款是否构成对无罪推定的合理限制.
Abstract:
The formal connotation of the presumption of innocence primarily focuses on the mecha-nism of proof,embodying the fundamental characteristics of formal rule of law and democratic human rights.However,this formal dimension fails to keep pace with developments in procedural law theory and institutional frameworks;it abandons indirect control over legislative power in the realm of substan-tive law and is incapable of responding to the challenges and erosion posed by security-oriented and pre-ventive criminal legislation and policies.The introduction of the substantive connotation of the presump-tion of innocence highlights the principle's constitutional status and its nature as a fundamental right,a-ligning with the requirements of substantive rule of law and the integration of criminal justice.The sub-stantive connotation addresses the blind spots of the formal connotation by extending the normative force of the presumption of innocence to areas such as sentencing and the disposal of property involved in cases.It assists the principle of legality(nullum crimen,nulla poena sine lege)in fulfilling the dual require-ments of substantive appropriateness and justice in defining the scope of crimes,allocating the burden of proof,establishing presumptions and defenses,and defining subjective elements.Restrictions on the pre-sumption of innocence should be subject to constitutional review through the principle of proportionality and its doctrinal system,particularly by maintaining a balance between the importance of the disputed is-sues and the defendant's right to defense at the level of the narrow proportionality test,so as to evaluate and justify whether contested provisions constitute reasonable limitations on the presumption of inno-cence.
刊 名 中外法学 ISTICPKU
年,卷(期): 2026, 38(4)
机标分类号: D915.3 D669.5 C91-03
在线出版日期: 2026年9月11日
基金项目: 25BFX138:国家社会科学基金,