摘要
在数字经济时代,个人信息对价化理念有助于提升消费者的隐私意识、帮助消费者重视个人信息的经济价值.但所谓个人信息对价化现象并不意味着"免费"数字服务合同必然采取有偿合同构造.因为在经营者普遍使用非必要个人信息商业利用条款的现实背景下,该理论无法回避《个人信息保护法》第16条的捆绑禁令,还造成了既有理论的体系违和,缺乏实益.解除非必要个人信息商业利用与数字服务的绑定,既有规范依据,也是数据合规实践的未来走向.将"免费"数字服务合同定性为基于营销动机的无偿合同,是更妥当的解释选择.根据《民法典》、消费者法和数据保护法的体系解释,无偿合同的定性并不会降低消费者保护水平.可以在相关制度构建中将"个人信息对价化"视作描述性概念.
In the digital economy,the concept of personal data as consideration helps enhance con-sumers' privacy awareness and encourages them to value their personal data.However,the theory of personal data as consideration does not imply that"free"digital service contracts must be construed as onerous contracts.Given that operators generally incorporate clauses for the commercial use of non-es-sential personal data,this theory fails to circumvent the anti-bundling prohibition under Article 16 of the Personal Information Protection Law.Moreover,it creates systemic inconsistencies with established le-gal doctrines and lacks practical utility.Decoupling the commercial use of non-essential personal data from digital services is supported by existing regulations and aligns with the future trajectory of data com-pliance.Characterizing"free"digital service contracts as gratuitous contracts motivated by marketing is a more appropriate interpretive choice.Based on a systemic interpretation of the Civil Code,consumer pro-tection laws,and data protection laws,this characterization does not diminish the level of consumer pro-tection.Consequently,"personal data as consideration"should be viewed as a descriptive concept rather than a normative one in legal system construction.