Impact of institutional cognition on farmers'continuous participation in the fallow system:An empirical analysis based on chain mediating effect model
摘要
[目的]公众对制度的理解、信任和持续参与是制度持续运行的重要基础.在多轮休耕制度试点陆续到期背景下,厘清农户持续参与决策及其关键驱动因素,对促进休耕制度可持续意义重大.[方法]本文基于制度经济学理论和社会交换理论,构建了制度认知影响农户休耕制度持续参与的链式中介效应模型,利用2019年西北休耕试点区微观调查数据、层次分析法以及Bootstrap法,对该模型进行实证检验,并进一步探讨了链式中介效应的政策异质性.[结果]①研究区休耕制度持续具备了良好公众基础,农户在试点结束后持续参与休耕制度的积极性较高,83.80%表示愿持续参与,且其中超过52.07%愿将耕地全部休耕.②制度认知能显著促进农户休耕制度持续参与,但该效应主要依靠改善"制度满意-制度信任"的链式中介效应和提升制度信任的简单中介效应共同发挥作用,而其直接效应和通过改善具有短期且不稳定特征的制度满意中介效应均难以产生显著驱动效果.③多群组分析表明,相比于高政策参与度、高信息透明度,低参与度、低信息透明度政策环境下依靠链式中介促进农户持续参与的效果更好;提供高补偿标准、给予管护工作机会,将更有利于发挥制度信任的简单中介和链式中介的持续参与激励效应.[结论]制度认知能有效促进农户休耕制度持续参与,其核心机制在于实现制度信任的简单中介和"制度满意-制度信任"的链式中介效应,且传导机制存在政策异质性.本文可从制度认知视角深化对农户休耕制度持续参与行为形成机理的理解,并为实现休耕制度可持续运行提供政策启示.
[Objective]Public understanding,trust,and continuous participation in the system are important foundations for its sustainability.Against the backdrop of the successive expiration of multiple rounds of fallow system pilot programs,clarifying farmers'decisions regarding continuous participation and the key driving factors is of great significance for promoting the system's sustainability.[Methods]This study used institutional economics and social exchange theory to develop a chain mediating effect model of the influence of institutional cognition on farmers'continuous participation in the fallow system.Using micro-survey data from the fallow pilot area of Northwest China in 2019,hierarchical regression analysis and Bootstrap methods were applied for empirical testing,along with further analysis of policy heterogeneity of the chain mediating effect.[Results](1)The fallow system in the study area had a strong public support base for sustainable operation.After the pilot programs ended,83.80%of the surveyed farmers expressed willingness to continue participating,with over 52.07%of these farmers willing to place all their cultivated land under the fallow program.(2)Institutional cognition significantly promoted farmers'continuous participation in the fallow system,primarily through the chain mediation of"institutional satisfaction-institutional trust"and the simple mediation of enhancing institutional trust.Its direct effect and the mediating effect of institutional satisfaction,which was short-term and unstable,failed to produce significant driving effects.(3)Multi-group analysis showed that chain mediation was more effective in promoting farmers'continuous participation in policy environments with low policy participation and low information transparency than in those with high policy participation and high information transparency.High compensation standards and maintenance job opportunities would enhance the incentive effects on continuous participation of both the simple mediation through institutional trust and the chain mediation involving institutional satisfaction and institutional trust.[Conclusion]Institutional cognition effectively promotes farmers'continuous participation in the fallow system,primarily through a simple mediating effect of institutional trust and a chain mediating effect involving"institutional satisfaction-institutional trust",with distinct policy heterogeneity in the mechanisms.This study deepens the understanding of the underlying mechanisms behind farmers'continuous participation in the fallow system from the perspective of institutional cognition,and provides policy implications for ensuring the sustainable operation of such programs.