A Revisit to the Relationship Between Mind and Li:A Historical Investigation into Daoxue Centered on the Notion of"Mind Is Li"
摘要
道学史上关于心与理(性)关系的讨论,有两个关键节点,涉及理学与心学两方代表人物,其一是宋代的朱熹和陆九渊,其二是明代的罗钦顺与王阳明.朱子对此问题的讨论有较完整的理论视野,从正面来说,朱子既主张心即理、心与理一,又主张心性有别;从反面来说,朱子批评心学与佛学忽视气禀之杂,导致认欲为理、以知觉为性,无法真正落实心与理一.之后罗钦顺的批评思路仅限于心学忽视气禀之杂,并将心学与心即理说混同起来;这与阳明心学主张心即理、批评朱子学析心与理为二的思路恰相对反."心即理"乃道学通义,是程朱陆王共许之义,可见罗钦顺已被其所批评者束缚住了.从宋代的朱陆之争到明代的罗王之辩,两方对心理关系的争论变得越来越激进和尖锐,也变得更加狭隘.后世那种认为"心学认同心即理、理学否认心即理"的说法,正是从第二个节点才正式确立.对心理关系问题的道学史溯源工作,当有助于我们重获探究此问题的完整视野,并重审道学分派及其标准等问题.
In the history of Daoxue,discussions on the relationship between the mind and li hinge on two critical junctures,involving key figures from both the School of Li and the School of Mind:Zhu Xi and Lu Jiuyuan in the Song Dynasty,Luo Qinshun and Wang Yangming in the Ming Dynasty.On the positive side,Zhu Xi not only upheld that"mind is li",asserting the fundamental unity of mind and li,but also maintained that mind and nature are distinct.On the negative side,he criticized the School of Mind and Buddhism for overlooking the diversity inherent in physical endowment,which led them to mistake desires for li and perception as nature,thus failing to actualize the unity of mind and li.These positive and negative arguments together reveal the comprehensive theoretical scope of Zhu Xi's philosophy.Subsequently,Luo Qinshun's critique focused exclusively on the School of Mind's neglect of the diversity of qi,and conflated the School of Mind with the doctrine of"mind is li."This stands in direct opposition to Wang Yangming,who maintained that"mind is li"while criticized Zhu Xi for analytically splitting mind and li into two.In fact,"mind is li"is a shared interpretation of Daoxue tradition,affirmed by Cheng,Zhu,Lu,Wang;thus,Luo Qinshun was ultimately bound by the very object of his critique.From the Zhu-Lu debate in the Song to the Luo-Wang dispute in the Ming,the controversy over the mind-li relationship grew increasingly radical,acute,and narrow.The later conventional view—that"the School of Mind affirms'mind is li'while the School of li rejects it"—was formally established only at this second historical juncture.Tracing the genealogy of the mind-li issue in the history of Daoxue may help recover a holistic vision for re-examining this issue and reconsider the divisions and criteria of Daoxue tradition.