Dynamic Systems Theory of Invalidating Contracts Violating Financial Regulatory Rules for Being Contrary to Public Order and Good Morals
摘要
金融监管规章借助公序良俗条款判定合同效力是金融风险协同治理的现实需要.然而,司法实践中违反金融监管规章之合同的悖俗审查既面临论证科学性不足、说服力不强的缺陷,还存在诱发公序良俗条款的泛化适用倾向.动态系统论借助"弹性规范+动态体系"的柔性构造能够有效克服上述弊端,有利于公序良俗条款的司法适用.可构建违反金融监管规章合同"悖俗无效"的动态评价框架:首先,以不伤害原理、合同自由原理和比例原则构成的内在体系为基础,提取出非私人利益的损害程度、私人利益保护的正当性以及合同无效评价的适配性三个要素;其次,根据各要素的充足程度、要素间的协动关系,将问题转化为公法管制与私法自治在金融领域的利益博弈;最后,明确基础评价和原则性示例,以此为评价基准并结合个案具体情况综合判定合同效力.
The reference to the provision regarding public order and good morals in financial regulatory rules for adjudicating the legal effect of contracts is a practical requirement for the collaborative governance of financial risks.However,in judicial practice,the review of whether a contract violating financial regulatory rules is against public order and good morals not only faces the shortcomings of insufficient scientific argumentation and weak persuasiveness,but also exhibits the tendency of overgeneralized application of the provision regarding public order and good morals.The dynamic systems theory,with its flexible structure of"flexible norms+dynamic system",can effectively overcome these drawbacks and contribute to the judicial application of the provision regarding public order and good morals.A dynamic framework can be formulated for assessing whether a contract violating financial regulatory rules is invalid due to being against public order and good morals.Firstly,based on the internal system composed of the principle of no harm,the principle of freedom of contract,and the principle of proportionality,three elements are extracted as follows:the extent of damage to non-private interests,the legitimacy of protecting private interests,and the suitability of the determination of contractual invalidity.Secondly,according to the sufficiency of each element and the interaction among them,the issue is transformed into a game of interests between public law regulation and private law autonomy in the financial field.Finally,the basic assessment and principled demonstration should be clarified to serve as the assessment benchmark,and in combination with the specific circumstances of individual cases,to comprehensively determine the legal effect of the contract.