军事知识服务平台
论分工合作结构下过失行为危险性的判断
On the Determination of Dangerousness of Negligent Conduct under the Structure of Division of Responsibilities and Cooperation
摘要 涉分工合作的刑事过失案件中,过失行为认定的困难源于事故结果常由多个相互影响的独立违规行为共同导致,使单个行为的危险性难于判断.原则上讲,他人的违规后行为是其自主决定的结果,无法为前行为人所预期,亦不可视作前行为危险性的判断素材.但是,如果前行为人行为时基于经验事实或规范判断,已然无法期待后行为人以合规行为来控制危险,则应例外地将违规后行为升高的危险也作为前行为危险性的自然延伸,由此肯定前行为的致果危险性.分工合作结构下,分工内容本身会成为前行为人能否期待后行为人控制危险的依据,在相应内容昭示了违规后行为可被预期的情况下,即可经由一体看待的思路将前行为也认定为过失行为.
Abstract:
In cases of negligent criminal cases involving division of labor,the difficulties in determining the negligent conduct stems from the fact that an accident is often jointly caused by multiple independent while interrelated violations,which makes it hard to assess the dangerousness of each violation.In principle,a subsequent violation committed by another person is the result of that person's autonomous decision-making,which cannot be anticipated by the prior perpetrator,or considered as a factor for assessing the dangerousness of the prior conduct.However,if the prior perpetrator,at the time of committing the conduct,based on empirical facts or normative judgment,cannot expect the subsequent perpetrator to control danger through compliance,then the escalated danger resulting from the subsequent violation should exceptionally be taken as the naturally extended danger of the prior conduct,thus confirming the dangerousness of the prior conduct in resulting in the consequences.Under the structure of division of responsibilities and cooperation,the content of divided responsibilities itself can serve as a basis for determining whether the prior perpetrator can expect the subsequent perpetrator to control the danger.If the corresponding content indicates that the subsequent violation is foreseeable,then the prior conduct may also be deemed as a negligent conduct under a holistic assessment approach.
刊 名 政治与法律 ISTICPKU
年,卷(期): 2026, (9)
分类号: DF622
机标分类号: D924 F279.246 TU111.19+5
在线出版日期: 2026年10月19日